Craig Melton on DATING!!! – with Logan Ury
June 16, 2023
Amanda Doyle:
Welcome back to We Can Do Hard Things. We are very excited today because we have this specialest guest ever, Craig Melton. You know him, you love him. He’s a damn national treasure. And he is here with Logan Ury, who is a behavioral scientist, turned dating coach, and the author of the best-selling dating book, How to Not Die Alone: The Surprising Science That Will Help You Find Love. Our last episode, if you have not listened, you have to go back. Abby, Glennon, Logan and I had a fascinating conversation about really what’s under dating, how the hell you date as a grownup, how you can be true to yourself to find who you want to attract into your life, significant others, including a partner or also just delightful folks you want to fill your life up with and expand your life.
Amanda Doyle:
And today we are taking that wisdom and making it practical and concrete with our very own Craig Melton. Craig is not only my beloved brother-in-law, he is Chase, Tish and Amma’s father and co-parent of them with Glennon and Abby, and he is also a man on the scene, as it were. For about seven years you’ve been dating, Craig, is that right?
Craig Melton:
That’s about right. Yeah. Wow.
Amanda Doyle:
Thank you for being here. And as you will note, Glennon and Abby are not, so speak freely because we are actually looking contrary to what she indicated on the last podcast. We are looking for you to find your person, not necessarily a sister wife.
Craig Melton:
Well, thank you for having me.
Amanda Doyle:
Logan is here to talk to us about you and what you’re looking for and patterns and how to find what you’re looking for. So get us up to speed on where you are, Craig, in your current situation.
Craig Melton:
I’ve been dating somebody for three months and I guess my dating ever since seven years ago, the whole process has evolved a bit. I was married 14 years and back in the day before there were apps, you met people just out and about. And so coming onto the scene, learning the apps, learning how to navigate that, has been a bit of a process. The place that I’m at now in the South Bay, there’s a lot of single people, so you can meet people more organically out and about, and that’s where I met this person. I feel like it’s a more natural way you can get to know somebody where there’s no filters and people fabricating their age or what have you. So it’s early on, but that’s where I’m at now.
Logan Ury:
Great. All right. Craig, I am going to treat this a little bit like a coaching session, but push back if it gets too personal.
Craig Melton:
I’d love that.
Logan Ury:
Just want to see, how do you feel right now sitting here and talking publicly about your dating life?
Craig Melton:
Definitely nervous, but I’m open-minded because I know that there are obviously patterns that you bring into each, that I’ve probably just continued to have from relationship to relationship, and so I’m willing to unpack those, but I’m definitely nervous. Why not? No one likes to hear about the negatives about patterns that might not be helping the relationship.
Logan Ury:
We can also frame it in terms of opportunities, what to do differently moving forward, what to keep the same. When you look back at the last seven years of dating, what are some of the patterns that you recognize? So where were you usually meeting these people? Who usually ended it? Were you the same person in all these relationships or do you feel like you showed up as a different person? Talk to me about what those seven years have been like.
Craig Melton:
Sure. It also depends on the geographic area that you’re in as well, because being in the previous place in Naples, a lot of my friends were married, with kids, and so I didn’t go out a lot. I think the opportunity to meet people was more online, and so I had to learn that a bit worse versus now where people, there’s just more single people, so you can meet them organically out and about. But I think I was looking for some perfection after divorce. There were just little things that looking back that I wouldn’t do today. I was the one to end things a lot. I was the one to say, okay, this is a non-starter, and it might have been a little thing, but I held onto that little thing and just said, nope, I can do this next part of my life the way I want to do it. And so why compromise?
Craig Melton:
If this thing is bothering me, I don’t have to just accept it. So looking back, there’s some things that I probably was a little bit too picky about. Now I think I would probably work through it. I think I’ve evolved a little bit there, but I think, yeah, I was definitely the one to end things just because of little nitpicky things that right outside of the divorce, I was like, I’m not going to go for that. I’m not going to do this. This is a non-starter.
Logan Ury:
I heard you took the quiz on my website and you’re a maximizer.
Craig Melton:
Yeah. Tell me about what that is.
Logan Ury:
Maximizer, you really just described it in your own story, which is feeling like, okay, there could always be something better out there, being really picky. I think for you, the narrative is I got married, I was married for 14 years, it didn’t work out. So if I’m going to do it again, it better be perfect. And so really holding your next relationship to a really high level, instead of maybe saying, I’ve seen the reality that no relationship is perfect and it didn’t work out the first time, so I’m going to have a more realistic view of what partnership can be. It seems like you were like, well, when I do it again, this time I better get it right. And so why don’t you tell me a little bit about some of the things that you broke up with people in the past that maybe looking back you’re like, wasn’t actually a huge deal.
Craig Melton:
Oh gosh. Some of those were situational. And also if I look back on a pattern being in the area that I was a very conservative area, and so there were some certain beliefs and things that I felt maybe didn’t match up. So I know a pattern. I dated a girl who was two hours away for a while, so I would date out of town, and that worked for a time period. But then there has to be a point where, okay, is that person going to move here? Am I going to move there? And when you then have kids involved and co-parents, it becomes difficult. There was times when I would break up with somebody because I was moving to Los Angeles and I wanted to start fresh. There were certain instances where somebody maybe was a little controlling, and I just didn’t think that that was a healthy relationship, especially if that’s happening in the early parts of dating. I was thinking in my mind, if I fast-forward 10 or 15 years, how bad is it going to get?
Craig Melton:
There was some insecurities, and I think everybody’s insecure, but there’s a fine line between being a little bit insecure and then being totally insecure where that person can’t trust themselves, and they’re then almost projecting that on me. So those are some of the reasons why I ended things. And also I think some of it was timing. Right after the divorce I wasn’t looking to get right into a serious relationship. And so there were times when the woman would get really close really fast, and I think it was just too quick, it was too soon for me to get that serious that quick.
Amanda Doyle:
I don’t even know if I’ve ever heard, are you looking for, I want a serious long-term partnered potential/spouse. Is that what you want?
Craig Melton:
That’s a good question. I didn’t want that for the longest time because I wanted to try to navigate and date and figure out what I wanted. But recently, the last six months I’ve been dating out here in Los Angeles, and there’s some pros and cons to being in an area where there’s a lot of single people. But yeah, I think I am ready. I am ready to find somebody that I want to just settle down with and be present with that person and integrate with the kids and have all of that. Because dating, there’s some good parts about it, but it’s exhausting sometimes too. So yeah, I think I am ready.
Amanda Doyle:
Well, that’s exciting, Craig.
Logan Ury:
It’s really exciting.
Amanda Doyle:
I’ve never heard you say that.
Craig Melton:
I know.
Amanda Doyle:
That it’s just like you’re ready for a more consistent integrated part of your life to bring into all the parts of your life person, and that’s a very different kind of person than maybe someone who’s like, hey, two hours away and lots of fun. That’s a totally different relationship. Okay, now I’m out of my, what I know about life, so back to Logan.
Logan Ury:
No, I love that. But Craig, I just want to validate you for a minute and say, I was thinking that you might say almost like these things that Jerry Seinfeld used to break up with people on his show where it was like, I didn’t like the way she ate peas, or I didn’t like the way she pronounced this word. I actually think what you said is super reasonable. It’s like, too controlling? Yep. Sounds like a relationship to get out of. Or two hours away with no timeline for living in the same city, that’s also reasonable. And so I just want to give you the confidence that you probably know more about relationships than you’re giving yourself credit for, because I think that’s some of the beauty of dating after divorce, dating in your 40s and things like that, is you have a much greater sense of who you are.
Logan Ury:
When you and Glennon met, you were probably such a different person from that now, and now you get a reset and you get a chance to choose someone who suits who you are today, not who you were in high school or in your early 20s.
Craig Melton:
Right. Yeah, thank you. There were some nitpicky things, but I think I over-
Logan Ury:
Let’s hear them.
Craig Melton:
No, I would overlook, there were some things like, for instance, there was some hygiene things. If somebody was super messy in the bathroom, I would overlook that. But those were things you’re just like, okay, if that’s something that’s happening now, I feel like the first, whatever, you probably know more than this, with the honeymoon period, I don’t know when that lasts, 18 months, 12 months. But if things are messy, whether it’s a messy car, if it’s somebody who talks over you, those are little things that I would look over, I would’ve a conversation about. And if it didn’t improve, then that would be maybe a reason to talk further about it.
Logan Ury:
One lesson that I’ve learned through my research that’s been really helpful to me in my relationship is that the Gottman’s who are the godfathers of relationship science, found that 69% of problems in relationships are perpetual. So what they mean is they don’t get solved. So for example, I’m an earlier, on time person. My husband is a late person. I have asked him for eight years to change and he will not. And what that means is that sometimes we go to the airport at different times. And so understanding that every relationship has problems and that you’re choosing a set of problems that you can live with, not just looking for relationship without problems or looking for a person you can change, I think that that’s given me a zen feeling around it, which is like, yep, I chose this person with this set of problems and I can cope with them. I’m not looking for the day where he’s going to want to be super early to go to the airport.
Craig Melton:
It’s picking your battles, right?
Logan Ury:
Yeah. And picking the set of problems that you can cope with as opposed to being a maximizer and looking for someone with whom there’s no problems.
Craig Melton:
I think that’s a good point, because I think early on I wouldn’t settle for a lot of those things. Those are things that I would be like, I can’t do that. If you’re late and I’m early, then that’s a red flag. Because I feel like being early to something, being on time is important, or having a device, having your phone on the table when we’re eating, that’s a non-starter. If you’re on the phone, that person, your Apple Watch, that person is more important than me. Right? Unless that person has kids and you just specify, hey, I’ve got a babysitter, that kind of thing. But there were some things that are non-starters. I think I’m at now, I’ve evolved to a place where I’m going to accept certain things that I think are just part of relationships, and obviously there’s no perfect person,
Amanda Doyle:
But you get to choose those, right? Isn’t that the beauty of being on the open market? Is that you get to choose the particular problems that you’re like, yeah, can live with that one. If you decide the being late and you’re a different person than Logan. If you’re like, nope, being late is not one of my ones I’m going to choose to live with or the phone thing. But other people might be like, yeah, it’s annoying, but I can roll with it. But you actually are the chooser of that.
Logan Ury:
You do get to choose it, and it’s empowering. But a big message that I work on with my clients is the difference between a pet peeve and a deal breaker. I find that as we get older we put more and more things into the deal breaker as Craig called it, the non-starter category. And so an analogy that I like to use is that when you’re dating in your 20s, it’s like a startup, two people coming together, forming a company, and it’s messy, but you figure things out together and you’re on a team. When you date in your later 30s, your 40s and beyond, it’s like a merger, two completely formed companies coming together each with their own HR department, each with their own CEO, each with their own policies. And mergers are really hard because both people think that they’ve figured it out.
Logan Ury:
And so Craig, you are in a position where when you date, it’s going to be more of a merger. And so there are going to be moments where you have to compromise. But as Amanda said, you get to decide what you’re willing to compromise on and what you’re willing not to compromise on. But I think the more that you can look at something as I would prefer that that not be the case, but it’s not a deal breaker, the more people that you’ll welcome into your life and then evaluate for the stuff that really matters, like how they make you feel versus something that maybe you wouldn’t choose it, but it doesn’t mean that you couldn’t be great long-term partners.
Logan Ury:
So it sounds like over the last six months there has been a shift. What do you think happened? Do you think it’s just maturing? Is it getting clear on your goals? Because I think you are where a lot of people want to be, which is really making that shift towards getting closer.
Craig Melton:
I don’t know if there was a definitive moment that I was just like, yes, this is it. I think dating out here, I really value a lot of the East Coast. I’m seeing a different trends of people out here versus the East Coast dating, which there’s some things like being on time, showing up when you say you’re going to showing up, there’s a lot of beautiful people with options, and I feel like the consistency is not here. With that said, I’ve met a lot of great people, some people that I’ve been on a date with that I’m actually really good friends with now. But I think it’s just maybe evolving over time just to understand, okay, these are things that I want. These are things that I don’t want. And understanding like you were saying, what I’m going to compromise on, it’s been seven years and I think it was just something that just came up and just ready to explore a different phase of my life now.
Logan Ury:
I love that. Amanda, have you seen that shift?
Amanda Doyle:
This is the first time I’ve ever heard it from Craig. I’ve heard you dance around it. It’s wanting to have someone more consistently in your life. You have so much to offer, Craig, it’s just crazy. You’re just such a beautiful person and you’re so full of love and you’re so generous, and you’re always looking at the best side of everyone. There’s people who always look to be offended, and there’s people who you would have to really go out of your way to offend them. And it’s just because they have this security of a tree trunk. That’s what I feel about you, Craig. And I’m just so excited for you. And I just want for you to have what you want, because there’s a billion people that could fall in love with you, and you’re so good at making people happy that it would be easy for you to sign up for any of those relationships.
Amanda Doyle:
Because you’re an easygoing, really adaptable guy. And so when I think about it, I’m just like, what I would love is for you to be like, no, I want that, because it’s going to be really hard for you to say over and over, not that, not that, not that. Because you’re going to have a thousand opportunities. I just want for you what you really most want.
Craig Melton:
I appreciate that. And I think in the past I was a people pleaser and I’ve evolved to not. And so I feel like I’m the one that’s the bad guy for ending things. But I feel like it’s also healthy for me to do that as early as possible if something doesn’t feel right.
Logan Ury:
One of the ways that I think it’s helpful to know, am I breaking up with this person for the right reason, is to get really clear on what you want. And so do you have a vision for what you want your life to be like? Paint a picture for me of how are they integrated with your family? What are you doing on a Sunday? What does that look like?
Craig Melton:
I feel like this person would be integrated in as much as my life, whether it’s going to soccer games for the kids or holidays. Obviously there’s a dynamic with their family as well. There’s that kind of variable. But yeah, I think this person’s going to be at family dinners, that kind of stuff. I think that’s what it should be. There should be integration as much as possible.
Logan Ury:
And who are you around this person, whether we’re talking about the person you’re dating now or the person you want to end up with, which side of Craig do you get to be in the relationship?
Craig Melton:
That’s a great question. I want to be my goofy self. I want to be goofy. I want to be fun. If we say on a Saturday morning, if we want to go hiking or to the beach, I want this person just to be always up for anything, because that’s how I am. If there’s something fun we want to do or you just want to relax, be a natural flowing into life, it’s not going to be resistant and pushing back and say, no, I don’t do that on this day. I think they’re just going to be easy to be with, and that’s how I am.
Logan Ury:
I love that because I think I’m a people pleaser. Many of us are people pleasers, and part of that is being good at being a chameleon. And so maybe it’s a part of yourself that you admire. I can be in any situation and be a certain way, but what that can sometimes mean in relationships is that you wind up with somebody who’s sort of dominating the relationship and you always end up doing what they want to do because you’re flexible and you can fit in. And it sounds like what would make you really happy is somebody who can match that flexibility and who really is less rigid, is spontaneous and really wants to soak up all the juiciness of life with you. And so when you’re thinking about your relationships, I think it’s not about do I end it because of this small thing, but is this a person who can be my teammate and who I can see myself living the life that I want to live with them?
Craig Melton:
Sure. And I think, you hit on the point of another pattern, is I have typically gone for somebody who has been dominant. Type A dominant, roll with that person’s plans. I think I’m at a point now where I’m like I want to try something different, try something different where maybe I can be the one to plan, to come up with things. And obviously that person has equal say in everything, but the person will be flexible in whatever we do and just joyous, happy and spontaneous and empathetic.
Logan Ury:
What I see for you with Craig 2.0 is you taking up more space in a relationship and you really being like, I am bringing what I want to to this relationship. I’m going to come up with this plan for the weekend. I’m going to suggest this thing. And it’s like somebody who celebrates when you are in your full power and when you step into that versus somebody who’s threatened by that, and that’s the thing that you can test in early dating. If they want to do something and you want to do something else, do you feel like you sometimes get your way? Do you feel like they welcome some conflict or do they shame you for it? And so really paying attention to when I’m the Craig that I want to be, do they celebrate that or are they threatened by it?
Craig Melton:
That’s something that I’ve been focusing more on the last six or seven months or so, is just being more direct with my feelings. That’s something that I’ve had to work on. That I was-
Logan Ury:
Totally.
Craig Melton:
… I didn’t inherit that. No fault to my parents. They just didn’t grow up with that model to them. And so it wasn’t passed down. And so through obviously therapy and a lot of things the last 10 years, learning how to be vulnerable and expressing myself and I’m still working on it. I realize there’s times even dating the last couple years where I could have done it better, but just recognizing that that’s something that I have to work on and trying to be more direct has helped me I think just set intentions and plan and be that person.
Logan Ury:
I’d love to do one exercise with you, Craig. If you’re game. So will you close your eyes. And it’s a year from now. And I want you to imagine that you are with the love of your life and you are so happy and you spend the weekends doing spontaneous things and you play beach volleyball and you cook a new recipe and your kids are all around you and you have this beautiful family around you. Okay. Do you have this image in your head?
Craig Melton:
Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Logan Ury:
What did you do during the previous year to get to that point? What are the actions that you took? What are the patterns that you broke?
Craig Melton:
I feel like to get there I have to be super intentional with what I want and also what this person wants as well, and make sure that we have this common goal to get there. I have to be direct with my feelings. I have to plan things and have not only a short-term goal, but I would think a long-term goal of what that means, not only a year from now, but five, 10 years from now. And just having the integration of the kids, even Glennon, Abby, everybody that’s involved to get there, because I think that’s a super important part of it as well.
Logan Ury:
I love that. Okay, open your eyes. That was beautiful. I feel like you just made your coaching plan for yourself. You know what you need to do. You really have grown so much I think since you started dating. And it’s like you actually have the plan for what needs to happen, which is intentionality, openness, honesty, and it’s just about in those micro moments saying, am I going to say how I really feel or am I going to go with the flow? Am I going to be the chameleon or am I going to be Craig? And I really feel like in a year you can get to where you want to go as long as you’re making that daily choice to be authentic and intentional.
Amanda Doyle:
I have a question just broadly for both of you. What is dating like while having this kind of ecosystem of co-parenting? I’m just curious what Logan, if you have any research on that and Craig of what your experience is like, because I would think it would be super intimidating or come with a little extra frothy something, to know that the person that you’re dating has another person in their lives, that they have a very intense history with and a very intense current bond with. And that’s before you even get to children and all of that. What is that like?
Craig Melton:
I think it depends on the person and their situation. It probably was intimidating for that person to see this part of my co-parenting life, and I think it probably was intimidating. I think that person would probably have to have confidence and understanding that it’s not like there’s physical feelings anymore, but it’s just we have this really tight friendship and this person’s going to have to integrate into it probably no matter what. And you’re going to have to be open-minded when you come into it. I think it might even be more intimidating for somebody that I’m dating who doesn’t have kids, who doesn’t maybe understand spending time with my kids, spending time with my ex-wife and her wife. That’s probably really intimidating. I don’t know.
Craig Melton:
I think it just probably goes back to communication and just saying, this is part of how I see my life and I hope you can integrate into it and we can do it slowly. Introducing to the kids is different now because they’re much older than it was when they were younger. Seven years ago I would consciously wait because I felt like if I introduced somebody to the kids this early and things don’t go well, it’s like I’m going to be breaking this person’s heart, my kid’s heart. But now I feel like it’s the opposite. I feel like I want this person to meet my kids because the kids are a good barometer of things. If they don’t get along, if there’s not effort, then I can’t be a fit, can’t be a match. I think there’s a couple of-
Amanda Doyle:
Haven’t they dropped the hammer before once?
Craig Melton:
They dropped the hammer once. They did, yes. And I respect that. I respect their-
Amanda Doyle:
When they dropped the hammer on that one person, and they did it, they just gave you feedback about an interaction. Did that feel like new information for you? Or when they told you that, were you like, some part of me knew that? I’m curious about that.
Craig Melton:
I think it was both. I think when I was in the relationship, sometimes when you’re in it, you don’t see other things outside that are happening. So I think there-
Amanda Doyle:
I do know what you’re talking about.
Craig Melton:
Looking back on it now, it makes sense, but at the time I was like, huh, okay. And I had to step back a little bit and just get their perspective on it. I think it was a little bit of both. It was new information, but I also realized it was a part of me that was probably maybe shielding that part of what I should have been paying attention to.
Amanda Doyle:
Do you, Logan, see this co-parenting phenomenon in your research? And is it different if it is a woman coming into a relationship like Craig would be dating a woman who would come into this unit versus a woman who has this phenomenon and she’s looking for a man to join her ecosystem? What do you usually see there?
Logan Ury:
I think the reality is that dating when you’re co-parenting is obviously more complicated. They’re not just dating you, they’re dating your ex and they’re dating your kids and you have a more complicated life for them to fit into. So that’s the reality. But there’s also some positives to it. So for example, as you said, your kids are sort of a litmus test, do they get along with this person? You also probably take your time more seriously and are probably better at judging people from the beginning, because maybe somebody else is dating somebody for a while and not really facing the reality of it not working. But for you, you’re like, if this person isn’t a good fit with my family, then I need to move on.
Logan Ury:
And so it’s like, if we’re all puzzle pieces, looking for another puzzle piece to fit into, your puzzle piece just has more edges, which can make it harder to find that matching piece. But it also means that when you match, you are even more connected, because there’s all these different parts that fit together. And so when you do find that perfect puzzle piece match, it’s going to be such an integrated, tight, long-lasting bond.
Craig Melton:
I like that.
Amanda Doyle:
And for you in particular with that, Craig, because you have a couple high profile people that are your co-parenting people and there’s a lot of people who know you. Is that strange? Does it add something? And do people know you, when you were on the online sites, do people know who you are when they’re matching with you?
Logan Ury:
I had the same question because you mentioned your ex on your Hinge profile. I’m like, do people know who this ex is?
Craig Melton:
There’s some interesting stories. I initially would just assume that this person didn’t know me or Glennon or anybody. But there were times where, I remember I went on this one date when I think when I first moved out here and the person just pretended they didn’t know. And at the end of the date, I went and I virtually looked this person up and this person was already following Glennon. So I felt like I had wasted an hour and a half at dinner explaining everything and my story when this person already knows. And so if this person’s already lying on the first date, I’m not going to talk to this person again. I would rather somebody just say, and there’s been plenty of people that said, just let you know, I already know your story, but I just want to hear it from you. And I appreciate that. I just appreciate honesty. I just appreciate somebody just telling me.
Craig Melton:
There’s been instances where somebody doesn’t know me or Glennon, and that’s great too because it’s just getting to know all of us as we are today versus whatever it was years ago. There’s been times where I’m like, if you just would’ve said that you knew me or knew of me or knew her, it would just make things a little bit more, it’s just more honest.
Amanda Doyle:
Can you, Logan, share your wardrobe test? Because I feel like, Craig, sometimes that I have known when relationships, you’ve been deciding, okay, it’s fine, it’s good, it’s good, there’s nothing bad happening here, but you have that little itchy, and I’m not talking about your current one because I haven’t talked to you about this one in the last three months. But in the past where you’ve been struggling with, do I stay or do I go, what’s happening here? And Logan has a little test that helps with this.
Logan Ury:
Okay. Craig, if you’re going to play along, you have to give me your gut reaction to this question. So if the person that you’re dating were a piece of clothing in your closet, so something that you own, what piece of clothing would they be?
Craig Melton:
A hoodie.
Logan Ury:
Great. Tell me why?
Amanda Doyle:
That was definitive and quick.
Logan Ury:
I love that. Very gut reaction.
Craig Melton:
I feel like a hoodie, it’s a comforting thing. I love hoodies and I feel like it’s just something when I want to be cozy, when I want to be casual, but comfortable.
Logan Ury:
I love that. And a hoodie is maybe something like if you wake up in the morning, it’s the thing you grab, right?
Craig Melton:
Yes. Yeah, absolutely. It can go with a lot of different jeans or shorts. I walk the dog in my hoodie and I feel like it’s my go-to in the morning.
Logan Ury:
I love that. You can be spontaneous in a hoodie.
Craig Melton:
Yep.
Logan Ury:
I love the wardrobe test question because when I’m talking to people about if they should stay or if they should go, they can get very in their head. Well, our families get along so well and we already have this trip planned for later this summer, and they start to really intellectualize it. And so I use this test to get somebody’s gut reaction and get them back into their heart and how they feel. And I’ve heard the craziest responses. I’ve heard my boyfriend is a ratty t-shirt that I wear to the gym, but I hope nobody sees me. Or my boyfriend is the little black dress that I know I look good in but is actually too tight and I don’t feel comfortable in it. Or really beautiful answer is my boyfriend is my favorite pair of pants that he chose for me, but I wouldn’t have chosen for myself.
Logan Ury:
And I feel like your answer is such a healthy one because it represents comfort, authenticity, spontaneity, and it’s really something that you would consistently choose.
Craig Melton:
I’m glad you like my answer.
Logan Ury:
I’m glad you have a hoodie.
Amanda Doyle:
I would love to, because you have done this online dating thing for low so many years, Craig, but I never once participated in this. And Logan not only has your Hinge, formerly up, profile, but she also has these five top line takes for online dating, which I think would be very helpful for our audience to hear about. So first of all, do you have any reactions to Craig’s profile, Logan, knowing what you have heard from him, if he were to ever get back on the scene, does it accurately represent him to the world?
Logan Ury:
Yes. Okay. So Craig, with your permission, I’ll do a little profile take down. Tell you what I liked and areas for opportunity.
Craig Melton:
Okay.
Logan Ury:
I think your pictures were really great. You had a lot of pictures that are clear headshot, show us who you are, what you look like. I felt like I understood what you look like and meeting you today, it’s very consistent. There was also a great photo of you playing beach volleyball, so that’s like the full body shot that people are looking for. And it was also an activity of you doing something that you love. So those are all things that in our Hinge research are important. You also showed your sense of humor. There was a really cute one that said, are you a dog person, because? And then a cute picture of you and your dog. I love photo captions and a way to bring humor there.
Logan Ury:
A couple things that I would shift. So in your prompt responses, so for people who aren’t familiar with Hinge, it’s basically these icebreaker questions that you have responses to. I felt like a lot of your responses were about what you were looking for in another person, which is great. But what I want to get from somebody’s profile is three things, what they’re like, what kind of person they’re looking for and what it would be like to date them. And so a good way to get that all in your profile is to basically think of all the prompts you can respond to as a menu and then choose from the menu different prompts that will really help you tell those different things. So for example, for what dating you would be like, there’s one that’s my typical Sunday.
Logan Ury:
So that’s a great way to talk about is your Sunday starting with berries bootcamp and a smoothie? Or is it starting with lying in bed all day, watching Netflix? And really paint a picture for somebody of what your life is like and they can decide, do I want to live that life with that person? And then for talking about yourself, I really love the prompt, two truths and a lie. First of all, it’s very engaging. People always want to know this one’s the lie. You’re a twin, not a triplet, but it’s a nice way to talk about different sides of yourself. And then for the one about what you’re looking for, there’s a great one about I’ll be ready to delete the app when, or green flags I look for. And you can talk about some of the things you brought up. So somebody who’s open, somebody who’s emotionally intelligent.
Logan Ury:
And so I think really thinking about a profile is your billboard and your chance to get some messages across, will help people be more intentional about really making sure that they use that space to tell their story and to really attract the person that wants the same things they do.
Craig Melton:
That’s very helpful, thank you.
Amanda Doyle:
I love that too because it helps weed out the other people too, because someone’s not just saying, okay, do I match what this person is looking for? It does double work of is this person the person that I’m looking for?
Logan Ury:
This is a huge thing. I have a class where I teach people how to make their profile. And a big thing that I talk about is instead of trying to attract everyone, you should try to attract the person that’s looking for the same thing you are. So we did this really cool experiment where we had 12,000 people in this experiment, and some people put on their profile that what they were looking for was a serious long-term relationship. And some people put that what they were looking for was somebody who was kind and open-minded. So one is more vague and one’s really specific. And what we found is that if you were looking for a relationship and somebody put on their profile that they’re looking for a relationship, you’re 17% more likely to message them because you have aligned intentions.
Logan Ury:
But perhaps even better, if you’re not looking for a relationship and somebody is, you’re 10% less likely to message them. And so people are dating and they want to weed out the people that are not looking for the same thing. Putting on your profile what you want is a really, really efficient way to do that.
Amanda Doyle:
It’s like you actually do want to have certain people swipe, I have no idea what these things are. You want some people to look like you.
Logan Ury:
You want disqualifiers.
Amanda Doyle:
Yes. You want that because it makes more likely the people you interact with to be qualified. That reminds me of your beige flag situation. Can you please talk about the beige flag?
Logan Ury:
Okay. We know what a red flag is. We know what a green flag is. What is a beige flag? A beige flag is something on somebody’s profile that just is a cliche and means that they fade into the background. So common cliches on Hinge profiles are, I’m most competitive about everything or the dreaded picture of the man holding up the dead fish. And basically at best, you fade into the background and at worst people disqualify you because they feel like this is a cliche. And so what I try to help people do is move away from beige flags and instead get really, really specific. There’s a rule in writing and in humor, which is the specific is universal. And so you might think, if I want to attract a lot of people, I’ll talk about my love of traveling and cooking. Nope, nobody’s going to even notice that.
Logan Ury:
But if you talk about how you don’t know how to ride a bike, let me tell you, so many people will message you and be like, on our first date, I’m going to teach you how to ride a bike. So the more specific you can be actually the more attracted people will feel to you.
Amanda Doyle:
I love it. Again, we are not trying to get the most number of people to love us, we are trying to get the right person to love us. Okay. This whole thing of the timing of when to get offline and get in real life. Can you talk about that and the fantasy situation?
Logan Ury:
Yeah. So a lot of people they meet on the apps and they’re like, well, I need to talk to this person for a long time to figure out do I want to meet up with them? And it’s such a big investment to meet up. And what they do is they really delay and sometimes they risk becoming pen pals. It’s just somebody that you’re messaging with but you don’t actually meet up. And what we found is that there’s actually this sweet spot of after three to five days of chatting, that’s a really good time to say, hey, I’m really enjoying getting to know you, let’s see if we have as much chemistry in-person as we do over text, or I am going to check out this new Tapas place this weekend. Do you want to meet up with me? And so it’s really critical to shift from online to offline to see, not do I like the way you text, but do I like being around you?
Logan Ury:
And Amanda, I think what you’re referring to is I have this concept called the Monet Effect, which is that when we don’t have a lot of information, our brains fill in the gap in a positive way. So if I just know, I’m looking at Craig’s profile, I’m like, okay, he’s fit. He likes his dogs. I know a few things about him. Suddenly my brain fills in the gaps and I start creating a fantasy of him in my head. And the longer we go before we meet up, the more that fantasy grows. And so even if I meet up with him and he’s great as he is, because he doesn’t meet this fantasy I created, I’m inevitably disappointed. And so instead of creating that fantasy in your head, meet up with the person as soon as possible or do a video chat with them, but meet the real them, not the version of them that you’ve created in your head.
Amanda Doyle:
Oh my God. It’s exactly like Zillow. You know how if there’s a house and it’s like coming soon, but you don’t see all the pictures, but then you see the one picture and you’re imagining, oh, this is what the bedroom looks like, this is the bathroom. And you go see the house, it’s a fine house, but you’re like, but I had the house planned.
Logan Ury:
Dating is a lot like real estate, sadly.
Amanda Doyle:
And you’ve already told us, don’t post what you’re not looking for. We’re going to post what we are looking for. Ages, talk about ages, when people put their minimums and maximums on the dating app.
Logan Ury:
So one thing about modern dating is that it is very different from a bar. So if you walk into a bar and you look at different people and you think about who you’re attracted to and you start a conversation with them, you do not know how old they are. You do not know what they do for a living. You have not seen a picture of them in six different settings. You’re just meeting them as they are and seeing, do I enjoy being around you? But with the apps, it’s like there’s a bouncer at the front of the club and they’re saying, this is who gets in and this is who doesn’t. And so when you set your filters for things like age, maybe you’re saying, okay, I’m only going to date people who are 32 to 42, even though maybe there’s somebody who’s younger than that or older than that, then you would’ve been a good fit with, and if you’d met them out and about at a bar you might have clicked with.
Logan Ury:
And so I really encourage people to expand their filters. So subtract a little bit from the minimum age, add a little bit to the maximum age, open your geographic radius. It’s not that you’re going to date someone from all over the world, but if you really are more open-minded about who you’re able to see, then you have the chance to click with more people. Versus if you keep it really, really narrow, there’s probably so many amazing people that you would’ve had a great relationship with, but they’re not even showing up in your app because your bouncer has kicked them out.
Amanda Doyle:
So there’s this whole thing of the older men with the younger women, and I rarely see younger dudes with older women. We can cut this if you want, but what ages did you have Mr. Craig Melton when you did your profiles online?
Craig Melton:
So what were my parameters?
Amanda Doyle:
Yeah.
Craig Melton:
I would definitely change it now, but I had mine set for I’d say 28 to 48. It was a wide range.
Amanda Doyle:
So you didn’t cut it to below your age?
Craig Melton:
Mm-mm (negative).
Amanda Doyle:
All right. I’ll tell you what, 28 seems a little low.
Craig Melton:
It is, yeah it is.
Amanda Doyle:
Nothing against those ladies, but seems a little low to this dog over here. This is what I’ve always wondered, how the hell do we know, what percentage of people that are on these online sites are either not real or they’re scamming because they’re married or they’re unavailable and they’re just there to be, this is doing something for them on some level, but they’re never actually going to be authentically in a relationship? How many of them are there and how can you spot them so that you don’t actually engage with these people?
Logan Ury:
I don’t have stats around that, but I think video chats are a great solution to the problem. So if you feel like something is off or the person is not who they say they are, it’s definitely appropriate in modern dating to say, hey, I’d love to give you a tour of my house or introduce you to my cat, Mr. Snuggles, let’s hop on a video call. And I think when you just add that more information of I have your voice, I have what you look like, you’re seeing me, I’m seeing you, it’s more of a human connection. I think that really helps people cut through some of that confusion and just say, are we a good fit? And is this person the person that they portrayed on an app?
Craig Melton:
I’ll also say, if I ever get back into dating online, I would 100% do the video chat, because I’ve been on first dates where it didn’t match, the chemistry wasn’t there, and I feel like a five, 10 minute just casual chat, you would’ve gotten to that. You would’ve known that right away. I would highly recommend a video chat.
Logan Ury:
I think that’s another great thing that came out of the pandemic, is prior to the pandemic, when people would tell me about video chats, I’m like, nope, I don’t like it. You’re turning into a recruiter who’s doing a phone screen to hire somebody for roulez-vous, forget it, too corporate. But during the pandemic, that was really the only safe way to date for a while. And so the stigma around it has mostly gone away. And I think people are spending a lot more time FaceTiming in general. Why not just send them a little typo and be like, oops, I suck at typing, let’s just talk live or just find a cute little transition to get there. And I think having that sense of somebody’s voice, somebody’s sense of humor, do you have banter? You’re saving so much time.
Logan Ury:
And so I want people to move away from this idea of I need to chat for a long time over texting on the app to then decide if we should meet up, to I want to meet up with them or video chat with them as quickly as possible to decide is this somebody I want to invest in?
Amanda Doyle:
Yes. Craig, in your most honest self, what do you feel like is the biggest issue or obstacle or fear that you have to getting to where you want to be in terms of a partnered situation?
Craig Melton:
I feel like making sure this person is comfortable integrating into the family dynamic, I think is the biggest obstacle. I think it’ll be like the greatest blessing if it happens, but I feel like just introducing them to the kids and to Glennon and to my lifestyle and to sharing me with this part of it, I think is someone that’s going to have to be confident and comfortable in themselves and understanding. And I’m not saying this person can’t be involved in that as well, but there will be times when I’m at my kids games or I’m visiting college. There’s things that I may not be able to bring them all the time. And so this person’s just going to have to understand that, especially if let’s say they don’t have kids and they’re not used to sharing themselves with somebody else. I think that’s probably a challenge that I’ll have to navigate with.
Amanda Doyle:
That’s interesting that that’s your biggest anxiety about this, which makes sense, because that’s the center of your life, is your family. Do you find yourself subconsciously thinking, would Glennon and Abby like this person?
Craig Melton:
100%.
Amanda Doyle:
Would this person work?
Craig Melton:
100%. Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
At what level? First date, second date, third date?
Craig Melton:
No.
Logan Ury:
Even if somebody’s not co-parenting with them, they might even ask themselves, would Glennon and Abby like this person? That’s a nervous test for all of us.
Craig Melton:
Yeah. I’ve thought about that for sure. Not first or second date. I think if I’m beginning to like this person and then see them in my life and my kids, there’s all these different factors. So yeah, of course that’s something that I would think through for sure.
Amanda Doyle:
I wonder if, Logan, you have a perspective on it. Theoretically it should be like, who cares if Glennon and Abby like this person, it’s Craig’s person. Craig can’t be like, well, is this person compatible with all of us? It should be Craig’s person, and if Craig wants this person, that should be the question.
Logan Ury:
I actually like integrating them into Craig’s vision of love, because we are not single units that just move through the world. We’re integrated. We have community, we have a life. And something that brings Craig happiness is having a really integrated relationship with his ex-wife and her wife and having somebody who’s around their kids. And so no, when somebody’s going to be with Craig, they’re going to be with the whole family. And so I think thinking about will they fit into my beautiful vision of a life is realistic. And so of course they should make you happy and your happiness is number one. But my guess is that the person who does that is someone who’s going to really fit into your rich integrated life. I have a few closing thoughts I’d love to just share with the pod squad, around my advice for dating.
Amanda Doyle:
Please, please.
Logan Ury:
The first one is really know yourself. So do that relationship inventory, look at your past patterns, talk to your friends about why they are single. People can take the three dating tendencies quiz on my website and see, oh yeah, I am a maximizer. I’m always trying to trade up and I’m looking for the perfect person. And so the first piece is really owning who you are and figuring out what you want to change in the future.
Logan Ury:
The second piece is dating like a scientist. So you might think you know what you want, but maybe you’re wrong. And so date someone who’s different from who you think you should be with, and maybe that’s the person who makes you happiest long-term.
Logan Ury:
And then the third piece is, after a date, take the post date eight, ask yourself those questions. What side of me did they bring out? Did I laugh around them? Do I feel energized or de-energized? And really train yourself to date, to pay attention to who you are around that person and not just who they are on paper.
Amanda Doyle:
Love it. Logan, thank you so much for your time. Craig Melton, thank you for being so brave and sharing with us about your journey.
Logan Ury:
Yay. Craig.
Craig Melton:
Thanks for having me.
Logan Ury:
Thanks for doing this.
Craig Melton:
Thank you, Logan.
Amanda Doyle:
So exciting. I can’t wait to see who you end up with. They’re going to be the luckiest, luckiest little bird.
Craig Melton:
Thank you guys. It was great to meet you, Logan.
Logan Ury:
I’m so excited for you. It feels like there has been a big shift in the last six months, and I’m excited for that vision of yours in a year to come true.
Amanda Doyle:
Okay, everyone, if you haven’t listened to the first episode, again, go back and do that with Logan, Abby, Glennon, and me. And again, Craig, thank you so much. Thank you, Logan. And we’ll see you next time. Bye.
Glennon Doyle:
If this podcast means something to you, it would mean so much to us if you’d be willing to take 30 seconds to do each or all of these three things. First, can you please follow or subscribe to We Can Do Hard Things. Following the pod helps you, because you’ll never miss an episode, and it helps us because you’ll never miss an episode. To do this, just go to the We and do hard Things show page on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Odyssey, or wherever you listen to podcasts, and then just tap the plus sign in the upper right-hand corner or click on follow.
Glennon Doyle:
This is the most important thing for the pod. While you’re there, if you’d be willing to give us a five star rating and review and share an episode you loved with a friend, we would be so grateful. We appreciate you very much. We Can Do Hard Things is produced in partnership with Cadence 13 Studios.