ALOK: What makes us beautiful? What makes us free?
March 1, 2022
Glennon Doyle:
Okay, love bugs. Welcome back to We Can Do Hard Things. I just need you to be in a place today where you can really, really listen because we have sort of a heart mind shifting conversation here for you today. Untamed and most of my struggle in life and work is about trying to figure out who I am free from all the cages that culture built me to spend my one life inside of. So for all of us who are kind of on this freedom quest, Alok, I think of as a prophet calling to us from the wilderness.
Amanda Doyle:
Absolutely.
Glennon Doyle:
Showing us not just how it’s possible to break free of gender binaries, but how it’s possible to see break free from every socially constructed binary that does not allow us to live out our full humanity, our divinity, our infinite creativity and possibility. So what I want to insist to you is that the next hour of our lives is not about us understanding Alok, but it’s about us allowing Alok to help us understand ourselves and the situation in which we find each other and ourselves down here. So Alok is an internationally acclaimed writer, performer, and public speaker. As a mixed media artist, their work explores themes of trauma, belonging, and the human condition. They were born July 1st, 1991. So that was like last year for fuck’s sake.
Amanda Doyle:
We’re so old.
Glennon Doyle:
So hopefully Alok is three. In College Station, Texas, and grew up as the child of Ma… Can you say this for me?
Alok:
Malayali and Punjabi.
Glennon Doyle:
Thank you. Immigrant parents from Malaysia and India. Alok graduated at the top of their class at Stanford University, but come on who didn’t? And earned a master’s in sociology in 2013, they are the author of Femme in Public, published in 2017. Beyond the Gender Binary and Your Wound / My Garden. You should know the Alok, that all of them in our house. They’re the creator of #DeGenderFashion which is so exciting. A movement to degender fashion and beauty industries. Alok is committed to challenging what they call the international crisis of loneliness by creating public spaces for processing pain and establishing meaningful connection. Alok, welcome.
Alok:
I’m so happy to be here.
Abby Wambach:
Oh my gosh. Well, I have to ask first and foremost, this podcast is committed to talking about hard things and also respecting each other’s humanity. So, first I want to check in with you Alok, what is hard for you right now?
Alok:
I think when most people think about transphobia, they imagine physical altercations, bullying in public, but I think what’s most difficult about my life right now is the intimate violence that comes from within, the people who you feel should understand, but don’t. And the hard thing that I wanted to bring to this conversation today was transphobia that comes from women because I feel like it’s something that often doesn’t get thought about or worked through, but it’s actually what hurts me the most. Because I feel like feminism and specifically my mother and my grandmother created the conditions for me to have the audacity to own my own body. And I see my life and my gender as a continuation of a tapestry of women who had the bravery to say no, thank you. And for that love to be unreciprocated, I think creates a kind of grief in me that feels so overwhelming and arduous that it feels impossible to puncture, but we can do hard things.
Abby Wambach:
Oh my goodness.
Glennon Doyle:
Can you tell me what, when you say for that to be unreciprocated, can you tell me what you mean by that specifically?
Alok:
I see so much of what the trans movement being in the world is a love letter that says, I believe in your capacity for transformation, I believe in your capacity for self-determination. And then in response to that love, we’re told that we are wrong, that we’re disorderly, that we’re foolish, that we’re ridiculous, that we’re delinquents, that we’re predators, that we’re violent. That’s a pain that I continue to face as my words reach more people, is this extreme and coordinated backlash to tarnish me and by extension tarnish the ideas that have been here, they’re ancient ideas, because I think what patriarchy does is it makes us publicists. We find ourselves speaking it, doing it, living it, thinking it with such a fierce allegiance that if someone dare say another way of living is possible, people would rather eradicate and extinguish that alternative than confront that kind of spiritual nudity of asking, who am I outside of what patriarchy wants me to be?
Glennon Doyle:
Alok, you said the days that I feel most beautiful are the days that I am most afraid. Can you tell us what you meant by that?
Alok:
Yeah. I’ve been thinking about this a lot because there’s been a lot of negative self-talk in my head recently, when I look at photos and videos of myself, I’m so cruel. The first thought that populates is you look like a freak. You’re disgusting. Why do you do that? Why are you wearing that wig? Why are you wearing makeup? And I think people are surprised to hear that because they see images of me as this fierce, independent, incandescent light. But I want to remind people how insidious misogyny is, that as women and trans people, it’s going to take our entire lives to develop a self image outside of what men have taught us to see ourselves as.
Alok:
And so I have to literally sit and love on myself in that moment and remind myself, why am I doing this? Is this fear my own, is this hatred my own? And it’s not because when I was filming the project that I was filming where I look at the video later, I was so happy and I was so free and I felt so beautiful. And I would catch glimpses of myself in mirrors or iPhone screens and be like, I’ve come so far to be here and it’s so glorious to be here. And then in the aftermath, I find myself so mean.
Alok:
I think that’s because I’ve been punished for my beauty, my entire life. And by beauty, I mean, looking like myself, which I think most people don’t know that’s what beauty actually is. And so I’ve developed a knee-jerk response. That’s actually an antagonistic relationship to my beauty when I feel most beautiful I’m most afraid, not just because of what other people will do to me, but what I’ll do to myself, how I’ll censor myself, how I’ll look at that video and say, “You are a fool so tone it down.” And how I’ll tone it down and how easy it’ll be to blame it on someone else but to know, ultimately I made the decision.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
I get like a slightly different version of that. First of all, I love beauty is looking like ourselves. Is that what you said? Beauty is looking like ourselves. So I went on a show recently and Alok, my little dream was to go on a TV show with no makeup on because every time I go on a show, I just ask them to put all the makeup on because I get very scared of looking like myself. So it’s like different, but the same. And I was scared to do it because I was scared to look at it later, myself, not what other people were going to see, but what I was going to do to myself, seeing myself on a screen with nothing on. So yeah, I get that. I get that.
Amanda Doyle:
I wanted to ask you Alok, I feel like for so many that are in this clearly, this unprecedented attack on trans people is killing trans people and killing all of us at the same time. And it’s sometimes heartbreaking how far we have left to go. But as a fellow gender studies major like yourself, I resonated so much with how much you talk about how empowering it is to know our collective history and you say, “My faith comes from what was before.” Can you just talk a little bit to us about the tool that is erasing our histories and presenting it as new, disconnecting us from our histories and how that disconnects us to the direction where we would otherwise be going if we were more connected.
Glennon Doyle:
Because you said your ideas are not new, they’re ancient.
Alok:
Yeah. I mean, I just got word the Texas State Legislature, where I’m from, a politician there has included my book, Beyond the Gender Binary in a list of 850 books to ban in Texas public education. That is just such an example of what I mean, it’s that they disappear us, it’s not that we’re new. It’s that censorship has been an organizing strategy for hundreds of years. It looked like cross-dressing laws that made it illegal for people like us to exist in public. Abby, you and I would’ve been thrown into prison for just being outside. Women would be beaten for wearing pants. And when I tell people that they’re so shocked that they don’t even know that. And how did people get through the cross dressing laws? They went outside anyways. They did something very hard. They knew would be criminalized.
Alok:
And I have documentation of people who were arrested 20 to 40 times who in courts of law said, “I know who I am. I’m neither a man nor a woman.” I have evidence of that from the early 1800s. But why is it that those stories don’t reach us? Why do I have to go to university to go into archives to find those newspaper clippings? Why did it take me being an adult to learn that there were people like me who ran New York City nightlife in the early 20th century, we called ourself fairies and girl boys, androgens and inverts. We had so much language and so much love. Why, why, why? And then I realized, oh, it’s because when we have connection to ancestry and especially queer ancestry, then we know that there have been people who have felt the same pain that we did, and they still lived a glorious life so that we could, and that intergenerational connection of queer people is why I do the work that I do.
Alok:
I know that in my life, I might not see the end of transphobia, but I might be able to create something that allows the next generation and to feel like they can live a life that’s worth living. I want to gift possibility because that’s what my transcestors or my trans ancestors did for me. And so much of what I’m doing in the work is in tribute. It’s a living memorial to an ongoing pulse that says let’s do this decent human thing of being ourselves in a world predicated on our disappearance.
Amanda Doyle:
Also for you particularly culturally, and for so many folks culturally, being disconnected from your cultural roots through colonialism, the way that the long history of third sex, all of it, that was a part of your culture before colonialism. Can you talk a little bit about that? Because, but for European rule of many cultures, there wouldn’t have in this struggle. I mean, there would’ve been celebration of who you are.
Alok:
Yeah. Totally. It’s so funny to me that people accuse us as trans and non-binary people of imposing this gender conversation on them. When the real imposition was dividing billions of complex, divine, nuanced souls into one of two categories, man, and woman. And that was an orchestrated project of colonialism across the world. And what is now called the United States and Canada and where I’m from called India, where European settlers indoctrinated indigenous peoples into the idea that they had to be men or women as defined by your American culture. Otherwise they were heathen, degenerate, and wrong. And this looked like the extinguishing, like attempted genocide of gender variant people across the world. So what they do is they tell you that there’s only two genders and they get away with it because they kill, disappear, erase, discredit and delegitimize all of us who for hundreds of years have lived alongside you.
Alok:
What that’s done, I think perhaps even most insidiously is it’s made our own people tell us that us being queer is a marker of our whiteness or assimilation into the Americas. When I was a kid, I didn’t think that I could be both queer and Indian because I was made to believe that being Indian in meant I had to be straight. I had to be cis, I had to be married. One of the stories that I like to tell is that when I pierced my nose, my grandmother who lived with me at the time said, “How could you do this to me?” And what she was feeling, the surface is that in our culture, which is so family oriented and collectivist that I was betraying her by prioritizing me. But I think I want to have a higher level conversation, because that’s what I’m always trying to, or attempting to do in the world.
Alok:
When she said, “How could you do this to me?” What she’s also saying is how could you show me that freedom is possible. Because it’s easier. It’s easier to believe that this prison is a home. It’s easier to believe that this misery is the only way to live. And in watching and witnessing you own your own body, I have to confront the ways in which I’ve outsourced that ownership to other people, to culture, to identity. And so, so much of what the trauma I experienced from my own people, I know at the root comes from these histories of unprocessed trauma from colonialism, from so many of the violences wrought on them that made them feel like they were never enough.
Amanda Doyle:
That line, how are people so traumatized that they mistake freedom as a threat?
Glennon Doyle:
And doesn’t everybody on some level, experience that from their parents. How dare you show me, what’s possible, I’ve already lived most of my life. How dare you show me now what could have been.
Abby Wambach:
It’s totally true for me. I think that the truth of so many of us queer folks who had parents who in one way or another, or grandparents say, “How could you do this to me?” It is this freedom that we choose. And it’s like, they look at us with this disdain that they couldn’t make the same choice themselves on some deep cellular level. Women, especially, I think my mom probably being the parent of seven of us children probably looks at the way that her baby, the youngest child can go out into the world and try to break so many of these culturally constructed norms. And I don’t know, I just think that you are a fucking revolution Alok, and what you just said just is so true. For all of the parents out there, children are a revolution and they should be seen as so.
Abby Wambach:
What you just said about there was something that you wrote that really spoke to me and it goes along with what you just said, how could you do this to me, it’s like, when you first told your grandmother that you were trans. To me, that’s so important too, because I never got to tell my grandmother, I was too afraid. You were braver than me. There’s a part of me that feels like, oh, sad that she didn’t ever know me. Now that I’m strong and an adult and not needy of their approval being known even if, even if it does come with trauma, I still need to be known by our family. So I just want to read back to you what you wrote, how could you do this to me? And you said, “In her eyes, my journey was about hurting her, not about healing myself. She eventually passed on without ever seeing me as myself and at her funeral I had to dress as the man she wanted me to be, I wept for her and for me.” Can you talk about that?
Alok:
You know, Glennon, reading your book, one of the things that really stood out to me was how impoverished our definition of love is. How we’ve accepted conditional acceptance as love. And that one of the most powerful things we can do is to say, love has no buts or ifs or contingency plans. It’s a complete devotion to the other. The love that I grew up with felt so conditional, felt you had to be excellent. You had to be happy. I remember I wrote a poem about being depressed as a young person and my grandmother should have been in a campaign for iPad, because she would just be Googling me nonstop. So she discovers this poem. She calls my mom who calls my aunt who calls my sister, who calls me. And she’s so upset. Not that I was depressed, but that I’m speaking about it in public.
Alok:
The way that we talked about depression in my family was of course we’re all depressed, but that’s why we work hard. So what I really started to realize is the reason that love was conditional for me is it was conditional to themselves. They wouldn’t love themselves unless they were excellent. My grandmother literally worked so hard all of the time. And the only time I ever saw her free was when she developed disabilities, when she was older and couldn’t labor in the same ways. So she was forced to lie in bed and then being in bed she started to paint at the age of like 76. She started to take coffee grinds and spoons and things from the kitchen and make abstract paintings.
Alok:
She made thousands of paintings and she would say, “These are my real children.” I saw the myth of patriarchy. I saw how she was most free at the end of her life when she wasn’t what society called beautiful. I saw how that she was the most beautiful when she had her sleeves rolled up and was making these paintings. That’s why I came to the funeral. I came because I knew that people are complicated and I loved her and my love wasn’t contingent on her accepting me.
Abby Wambach:
Damn. Fuck.
Glennon Doyle:
I love that. I love that.
Abby Wambach:
It’s like the very thing we want, the very thing we want from our parents or our people, we have to give it unconditionally back to them.
Glennon Doyle:
Can I ask a question? I want to… I don’t know how to… I’m at the beginning of putting these ideas into words, so just be patient with me because I don’t have all the right words yet. But I have been just rethinking or understanding freshly some ideas about gender that I’ve had. A lot of this little inner revolution started by watching the TERFs.
Abby Wambach:
What are the TERFs for those who don’t know?
Glennon Doyle:
Can you give me a definition of-
Amanda Doyle:
Trans-exclusionary radical feminist-
Glennon Doyle:
Feminist, but how to describe.
Amanda Doyle:
Oh. Oh, okay. Well, Alok, tell me.
Alok:
No, Amanda, I would love for you…
Amanda Doyle:
If you’re looking at like social theory, there’s this idea of distinctiveness threat, where if we, anytime we place our identity very specifically in a group, then the uniqueness of our individuality becomes under threat when the boundaries around that group in any way become malleable. So for these radical feminists that have defined themselves completely as woman, and that is where they find their strength and their identity, instead of viewing the world from a mutual fight, the way that in fact, trans people and feminism align in our fight, they see trans women as the most threatening of all to them because if you can pass as me, what even is my identity, I have to put these walls very much around.
Glennon Doyle:
Okay. Then I’ll try to explain it this way. So watching them, I realized, oh, yikes. If that has anything to do with feminism, then I need to rethink what I mean by feminism. Because in Untamed, I write woman, woman, woman, woman, woman, woman, woman, woman, women, women, all the time. I Googled it once how many times I’m like, holy shit. I really identified with that word then and now when I listen to things, I’m starting to think differently about it because I’m thinking, oh, like a TERF if I’m a TERF, if your most important thing is protecting your idea of what a woman is, then that’s an over-identification with an identity. I don’t get that.
Glennon Doyle:
What I mean by feminist is I’m on the side constantly of whoever is getting the most fucked at the time. That’s it. So if a bunch of feminists are protecting women, as they see them at the exclusion of someone who is actually more under threat at that point than I’m not with them anymore. Also, Alok, I can’t find inside of myself when I get really still, I can find this thing that is like a wild moving faith inside of my identity. My real self. I can find creativity. I can find that energy that’s always… I can’t find any gender.
Glennon Doyle:
I can’t find on the inside of me, I can only find gender on me. I can find it like in my shirt and on my jewelry. And in my old remnants of Botox where I’ve like injected misogyny underneath my… I can find gender on me, but not in me. And I have friends, I have a close transgender friend who can find gender inside of them and that’s what they’re expressing. So my question to you is this idea of gender is a mandatory performance, but not born in us. Is that how you experience gender or do you experience gender as a real true thing inside of you that you’re expressing on the outside. And also does that question make any effing sense to you?
Alok:
Okay. First of all, Glennon, and it’s never about making sense. It’s about making sensation. It’s about what things make us feel, whether or not if they… Because in order for something to make sense, it has to pay allegiance to an idea that already existed and we want to make new ideas so we have to be speculative and experimental. And that’s why I’m a poet. Poetry is a laboratory for new ways of loving, thinking, and dreaming because in poetry, there are no rules. And that’s why I think everyone is actually a poet because it’s the anarchy of form where for the first time in my life, I had permission to say, make it up.
Alok:
I brought that attitude everywhere I went, I’m going to make it up. So first I wanted to say to what we were talking earlier about TERFs is it’s not just trans women, it’s trans and non-binary people are positioned as a threat that’s undermining the feminist campaign because what is happening is they’ll say that this gender theory is erasing the material reality of sex based discrimination. So it’s this idea that trans people are making it up and what’s real is being a male or a female. First of all, all language is made up. So when people say to me, “You’re making up new words.” It’s like plot twist, the word made up, was made up.
Alok:
What you’re upset about is that trans and non-binary people for the first time are speaking for ourselves and not being spoken for because what power and especially patriarchal power is, is the monopoly of the right to speak for other people. And so what is so threatening to these TERFs is that we are saying, I’m not actually a metaphor, I’m not a discourse, I’m not an idea. I’m not an an opinion, I’m a god damn human being. What TERFs are fighting for is not actually freedom, it’s the ability to do what has been done to them, to someone else.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes, yes.
Alok:
And that’s why I find it so difficult for me because feminism should about liberation from the need to even have power, because there’s so many more interesting things we have to do, like take naps. Power is not the goal. It’s not about overthrowing one system of domination to have another. It’s about ending the need for domination. And that brings me to love because what I’ve found, and I also have been so concerned by the uptick the United States where I’m having this conversation is not like the United Kingdom where TERFs have institutional power in the same way, but they’re winning the idea wars. So oftentimes their narratives become the first ways that people encounter people like me. So they’re told that we are some violent danger, menace to society. And I see people being like, do you actually know trans people in your life, or are you just… Where are you imbibing this from? You would think it would be very strange when the Republican party, a notoriously anti-woman establishment is opportunistically resourcing the rhetoric of protecting women and girls-
Glennon Doyle:
They care so much about that.
Alok:
When it comes.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Abby Wambach:
So funny now.
Alok:
It comes to black people, immigrants, Muslims, and trans people. What’s so scary about TERFs is that they’re resourcing the language of feminism. So that we’re all like, yes, empowering. Yes, totally great. But when the sand actually settles, what you see is something far more sinister. And so what I’ve found when I’m reading this stuff is what it is it’s a case of unprocessed grief and pain and rage. That’s why I manifested wanting to meet you years ago because you in another life could have been a TERF.
Alok:
Every incentive was there for you because you experienced so much brutality and injury from men, and you could have said, “Womanhood is the only way.” Elevated that, exalted that, but what you did is you dug a little bit deeper and you started to realize a kind of marrow that’s much more spiritual than that, that actually says patriarchy is an escape room. And it doesn’t matter who your character is. We’re all just trying to get out. And actually it’s about possibility. You write imagination over indoctrination. Only by doing that healing work, can we actually say, I don’t want to hot potato my oppression and misery on someone else.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Alok:
I actually want to end the hot potato.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Alok:
And then to your final question there, about what I feel about myself personally, I experience gender as it’s defined by other people, as an obstacle to my I spirituality. But gender as it’s defined by me is an exercise in my spirituality. And let me explain. They see gender as what I look like. I don’t see gender, I surrender to it. They say gender is about how I act, my mannerisms, all the things on the outside, my body. I see gender as a connection to my divinity. And so what people don’t remember when they don’t learn history, is that a lot of what we now call feminine garb was actually ceremonial wear that people would wear to receive God. And it actually was about spirituality. So the way that I dress is not because I want to be seen as a woman or be seen as non-binary it’s because I want to be a receptacle.
Alok:
I want to be a vessel for my purpose on earth. And that when I am dressed as myself, when I am myself, then I can channel truth and speak it. But for so long in my life, I was dissociated. I was a shell and I think y’all were too. And what my gender journey was about is less about finding my gender and more about being able to walk on the earth and feel it, being able to speak with a kind of conviction where my words actually landed. How I got there is what other people call gender, but what I call healing myself.
Glennon Doyle:
Okay. Okay.
Abby Wambach:
It’s like you-
Glennon Doyle:
I feel that.
Abby Wambach:
You just-
Glennon Doyle:
That caused a sensation.
Abby Wambach:
Summed up 20 years of my life in two sentences.
Glennon Doyle:
I just want to just want to real quick go back just in case any sweet love bugs who are listening are trying to put into context what Alok was just saying about, I could have been a TERF in another life and understanding that we don’t do to other people, what we are trying to escape from ourselves. And we don’t leave people behind. It reminds me very much of the mistake white feminists have made for so long with… It reminds me of Elizabeth Cady Stanton. It reminds me of, we are women we will identify more as women than anything else, which allows us then to when we are fighting for the vote to leave behind black people, which have happens again and again and again, because they didn’t identify with a more marrow part of the soul, which would’ve connected all of them and not let them leave each other behind. It’s the same thing in some ways, not all ways, but in some ways with gender, correct or incorrect?
Alok:
Yeah and historically, one of the things that often gets lost is the Elizabeth Cady Stantons and Susan B. Anthonys would tell black women an indigenous women, you’re not ready for feminism yet. You have to look like women as we define it and go through what we experience. So actually, what a lot of people don’t know is white women would go to indigenous reservations and teach indigenous women how to iron, how to wear blouses and corsets. The idea would be you have to experience sexism so that you can experience feminism. So rather than going to indigenous and black women and saying, can you teach me how to be free? White women said, “You have to experience my misery.” And we see the exact same stuff with TERFs now where they say, “You can only be a feminism if you do this, this, this, this, this, if you’ve been through this experience.” It’s that same sense of entitlement.
Alok:
But what I really am pushing back against in my work is I can’t reason people out of hatred. If I have to make an argument, a critical treatise on why I should not be attacked, on why I should be able to breathe, then you do not care about this conversation. So we have to go deeper. And the reason we have to go deeper is because we are not responsible for the pain, but we are responsible for the healing. What I want to tell TERFs and what I want to tell, and that’s what I began with saying that travesty of transphobia from women is I am so sorry. I am so, so, so sorry for the cruelty and misogyny in the world, but that does not give us permission to wreck that same damage elsewhere.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Alok:
We have to do the work to interrupt these cycles of violence and insist on a more dignified and beautiful life. And I promise you it’s possible. And that’s why you’re so irritated by us because you see also, another thing that TERFs do is they comment on our appearance. They say, “Oh, you’re a mockery. You’re like a joke, you’re disgusting.” They’re doing the same sexist tactics men did. Where in the early 20th century, when women were advocating for the right to vote, men would publish images to scare women from choosing the right to vote by depicting them as ugly. What did ugly mean? Wearing pants, having a beard, being masculine. So the idea would be you’re no longer desirable if you have political autonomy. What are the TERFs doing now to trans people? Look at these ugly people. I was literally just tagged in a meme the other day, trans rights activists are ugly, TERFs are beautiful.
Alok:
I was sitting there being like, what? This in the name of feminism. I think I really want to… Not to harp on this, but this is an urgent crisis. So often when I speak about this, people are like, this makes no sense, it’s counterintuitive. If you experience depression, why would you farther it? I want to interrupt that logic. If you experience depression of course, of course you want someone else to-
Glennon Doyle:
It’s hazing.
Alok:
Because you want someone else to feel that pain. Yes.
Abby Wambach:
Right.
Alok:
It is.
Amanda Doyle:
Well, and you’ve internalized it so much. I mean those early white feminists, it’s not that they were thinking consciously I want you to feel the pain I felt. They were thinking, they had so internalized the patriarchal model of model womanhood, that they were actually looking at indigenous women and saying, “You are actually not women yet until you match this.” So we have so internalized the trauma and the systems, these artificial definitions, we have become them so much that we can’t even interact. We have to bring you into patriarchy, then to free us from patriarchy.
Glennon Doyle:
Which is the danger of white feminism, right? That’s the whole thing. White feminism is so freaking dangerous because it’s just about bringing more people along into this death trap that we are in and getting a few of us a little bit higher in the hierarchy that already exists instead of doing what Alok said, which is, how do we get free from this need for power in the first place? Alok, I want to talk about beauty a little bit, because I think this is a touch point that probably most people listening will understand because they felt it on a daily level. You said in Grammar Lessons, I fucking love your poetry, Alok, I love it so much. “The body is three dimensional language. Beauty is the harshest editor.” Can you talk us about how all of us are controlled and dehumanized by beauty in the way that the world defines it, not the way that you define it, beauty standards.
Alok:
I’m so glad that we’re speaking when I’m 30 years old, because if we’d have this conversation five you years ago, I would not be ready to say what I’m about to say, I’ve gone through a profound transformation in my political analysis, I spent the bulk of my life and my career detailing the ways in which I was discriminated against, how insidious and violent these systems of oppression were. And now I’m kind of bored of that work because I realized the reason I was being discriminated was not because I lacked, but because I loved, was because of my power, I was only interpreting my life through their lens, which made me feel like I was wrong. When in fact I was a marker of everything that was right. So I began to revisit what was it that people called ugly in me. They called my body hair ugly.
Alok:
They called my skin color ugly. They called my features ugly. They called my femininity ugly. And if I trace all of those insults where they land, I love women. I love femininity. I love queer people. I love butts. I love sex. I love all of these things that they are using to degrade us. So they don’t degrade me anymore. They’re just testaments to my beauty, such that when I started to do this work, what I began to realize is it’s not what we’re fighting against. That’s the basics, we’re fighting against violence culture. Of course we’re fighting against hostility, transphobia, but what are we fighting for? I’m fighting for beauty. And a lot of people get confused by that because the only definition of beauty like love that they’ve inherited is so basic and flat that they just associate beauty with that commodity that we’re told, if you access, then you get power.
Alok:
That’s not what I’m saying. What I’m saying is beauty means your soul’s fingerprint on the earth that no one else in the world can have your beauty. It’s when I’m speaking to someone and I’m like, I could talk to you for the rest of my life because finally I can breathe again. The world for me is a series of drowning and then having conversations with people where I can finally breathe again and the reason I can breathe is because it’s you, it’s not that imprint of what you’ve been told. The cookie cutter sheet that says hi, I only know myself from my identities. So the work of beauty work for me is actually deep healing work to say, who am I outside of what I’ve been told I should be? Beauty is about that attitude of showing up and saying, I’m worthy of being here.
Alok:
It’s unruly. It’s riotous, it pisses people off. Once you find that beauty in yourself, you see it. Now what I was trying to track in my latest book, Your Wound / My Garden is I’m so much more happy and joyous because I see so much beauty everywhere. Despite every single attempt in the world to erase dissent., the season shifts, that’s a form of dissent.. The flower blooms, that’s a form of dissent.. We rise up, that’s a form of dissent. I go back to putting on my wig and my makeup, even though I felt I was going to throw it in the closet. That’s a form of dissent. Beauty is the natural orientation of the universe, the universe rioted first. And we are just following its lead.
Abby Wambach:
Aye yai yai.
Glennon Doyle:
Or maybe it’s Maybelline. Your Wound / My Garden. I need to read something from it. So this is from Alok’s latest for poetry collection. I don’t even want to call it a book. A sensation called Your Wound / My Garden. “One day when I die, rewind the heart attack, what power precipitated it? Unfurl the tumor, what policy prescribed it? Dissect the culture, not my corpse. Diagnose the world, hold one big stethoscope to it. Listen.” Alok, can you talk about the cycle of trauma? Because really what you’re talking about so much lately, what I understand that you’re talking about is how all of this, all of this political, all of this oppression, all of this anger, the TERFs, all of it has to do with trauma that happens to us and then we keep precipitating. So can you talk about the cycle of trauma in terms of how we oppress ourselves and each other and the toll it takes on our bodies, on our politics, on our freedom.
Alok:
So I know a lot of listeners suffer from the same thing. I suffer from 24/7 chronic pain. And when we look at the data, it’s predominantly women and trans people who navigate autoimmune disorders, chronic pain and chronic illness. I wrote that book because I was spending so much time in clinics. I went to dozens and dozens and dozens of doctors. And I was like, “What’s wrong with me? I shouldn’t be in pain.” And we did all the scans and we did all of the tests and everything made people say, “You’re perfect, you’re healthy. You’re great.”
Alok:
Then I started to realize, oh my gosh, it is easier and more cost effective to blame me for my injury, my pain than it is to actually say, this is misogyny. And I actually believe misogyny makes us sick. I actually believe that when I’m walking down the street and people are laughing at me and taking photos of me and spitting on me that when I’m logging online and people are saying lies about me, are literally just trying to fear monger as a way to make me into something that I’m not, that has a toll on my body.
Alok:
Such that it manifests physical pain because our body is trying to teach us, hey, this is not right. This is not safe. And so what I started to do is say, “Oh my goodness, I might never get safety out there, but I have to give safety to me.” And so what pain allowed me to do for the first time in my life, and Glennon, and you write about this and I really resonated with that. It’s not that pain is the problem, it’s that suffering is the problem. And so pain actually said stop. And so I stopped everything I was doing. I started looking at my life and I said, “Why did I mistake latent dissociation and a kind of suicide death drive workaholism as being alive?” No, I want to live so fully with so much vigor and zest and glamor that when I die, because inevitably that’s the only thing that we know, I’ll say, okay, cool, great. Next adventure. I’m there, no regrets, no remorse.
Alok:
Pain actually allowed me to start thinking about trauma, but then to start thinking about healing, I didn’t just stick there in diagnosing the wound. Why am I experiencing pain? What is this going through? I started to ask, the only reason I care to ask these questions is because some part of me is fighting for me saying, you want to be free. I think like many people suffering alongside with, and I write about this in My Garden too. It’s like, what preposition do we have to pain? It’s there, am I next to it? Is it in me? Actually in some ways taught me that all of the models that told me that life was going to be good. When I was younger I believed I’d stop being bullied when I grew up. When I was younger, I was told you’re going to meet the love of your life.
Alok:
Life is going to be picture perfect. Fuck that, actually life is going to be full of pain and so much confronting self doubt. And you’ll feel like you made it and then you hate yourself again. But alongside that is so much beauty. And so what I wanted to do in that book and the reason I called it that title is to show that suffering is a visitor. My natural orientation is love, care, peace, but then depression comes in, suffering comes in and it’s saying, notice me, the pain is saying, submit to me. And I do that. And then it goes, or it doesn’t go. But that doesn’t matter because what matters more is that I listen to it.
Glennon Doyle:
So all of our love bugs who are listening right now, the whole Pod Squad, we do something called the next right thing each week. So What is the next right thing Alok, something little, we call this, We Can Do Hard Things, but we don’t want it to be hard. What is the next right thing that we can do to face or free ourselves from the effects of trauma? If trauma is where all of this comes from?
Amanda Doyle:
Or to interrupt the cycle, if we have inherited our grandparents’ trauma and are trying, how do we step into that cycle-
Glennon Doyle:
And our culture’s.
Alok:
Forgiveness, self forgiveness. When you are being most cruel internally, you have to have some other voice in there being like, that’s not nice. Would I allow anyone to say this to my friend? Never. So that’s where you’re going to intervene and say, this is intimate partner violence, me against me. And I’m coming in and I’m saying not today. And even if it feels absurd, it’s really about stopping and in your head being like, no, I’m not going to tolerate that. And what I fundamentally believe is if we do the work of self forgiveness and self compassion that unlocks an unbridled compassion for other people, because we see the ways in which we are flawed.
Alok:
We’re idiosyncratic, we’re self sabotaging and ridiculous. So are other people, and so people always ask me, “How did you learn to love all these people who are so mean to you online?” And it’s because I realized I could have been them in the same ways that I was saying you could have been a TERF. Maybe I could have been a TERF. An my first response isn’t to say like, these people, these bigots that’s not right. It’s how did I get out of bigotry? The way I got out of bigotry is someone loved me and maybe that someone was me.
Abby Wambach:
Oh.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah. And you know what? Another next right thing we can do is read a Alok’s poetry. I mean when I listened to you just now talking about poetry, I realized, Abby knows I have to start my day with poetry. I can’t even, I don’t want to leave the magic space too fast. I’m just going to say words, because you told me they don’t have to make sense. I’m just going to say some words. I don’t want to forget about magic right away. And poetry is where I can stay in the magic. And I guess, I mean where people are just showing me their true, beautiful selves without the representative that’s staying inside of all the structure. A poem is like a love letter from the marrow that you were talking about. It’s like even sometimes when I’m reading a book and I love books, but even books feel too structured sometimes.
Glennon Doyle:
It’s like not a new, fresh thing. It’s like the first time I read Untamed to one of my dearest friends, Liz Gilbert, I had written it in an entirely different structure, the structurey structure. And she was like, “What is this shit?” And I’m not even exaggerating. That’s basically what she said-
Abby Wambach:
Yeah, she didn’t say shit.
Glennon Doyle:
She was like, “Your writing-“
Abby Wambach:
She was just like, “What is this?”
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah, wasn’t free enough. And I do think that poetry, if you start to read poetry or allow yourself to write poetry, it’s just a way of freeing that beautiful… The beauty that Alok is talking about, that’s been beaten out of us. It’s a way to wake it up.
Alok:
Can I be honest with you?
Glennon Doyle:
Please.
Alok:
I feel like I was put on this earth to be a poet and it’s so hard because no one wants to read it. And so everything else I do is about how do I get people to come and watch me perform a poem, which is the hardest sell. It’s like, hey everyone, like come and confront all of your deepest repression and trauma through poetry. It’s just difficult. I feel like we have to sugarcoat the medicine because people mistake the medicine as poison, and the poison as the medicine. But I truly feel so frustrated when all these people believe all these things. When all you can do is go read a poem. And then for the first time it will teach you education of the heart.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Alok:
That’s what poetry does is actually how to love more. Because when I read poetry, I’m constantly expanding and stretching because what poetry actually teaches me is that we’re all in this world together. And we’re seeing the same things and experiencing similar things. And we’re all in different worlds at the same time. And that I could read your poems… And to be honest, when I was reading your book, it’s the poetic lines, which speak to me the most. Every time I’m reading, it’s those zingers. Other stuff that’s like all just like, it’s setting up the ace shot. Wow. I just made a sports metaphor. Oh my God.
Glennon Doyle:
Look at you.
Alok:
I’m proud of myself. Oh my god. Wow. It’s really those lines. And that is how I write is I write backwards. I have the line because I’m a poet. And what a poet does is take a really complex idea, strip it apart, strip it apart, strip it apart, strip it apart, strip it apart, land it in that line. And then everything else is decoration.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Abby Wambach:
It’s like maybe the best compliment you could have ever given my wife.
Glennon Doyle:
Because my secret dream is to be a poet.
Alok:
But what if you already are one?
Abby Wambach:
I keep telling her, I don’t know when she’ll finally listen, maybe now she will.
Glennon Doyle:
Now that Alok told me. I’ll believe it.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah, of course.
Glennon Doyle:
I’m changing my bio tonight. We are going to end this conversation with Alok but don’t be too sad because Alok is coming back on Thursday to answer some burning questions from our Pod Squad of poets. We love you. This week when things get hard, don’t you forget that we can and do hard things. We’ll see you back here soon. I give you Tish Melton and Brandi Carlile.
Glennon Doyle:
We Can Do Hard Things is produced in partnership with Cadence13 Studios. Be sure to rate, review, and follow the show on Apple Podcasts, Odyssey, or wherever you get your podcasts. Especially be sure to rate and review the podcast if you really liked it. If you didn’t, don’t worry about it, it’s fine.