Jen Hatmaker’s Back! Forgiveness & the Audacity to Rebuild
August 9, 2022
Glennon Doyle:
Welcome to, We Can Do Hard Things. It’s our favorite thing because one of our people in all the land is back with us today. Her name is Jen Hatmaker. You may know her from all the other things. Okay? What we’re talking about today is this rhythm of life. Okay, and this rhythm of life that I started noticing was when I looked back at the time that my marriage imploded, my first marriage, because of infidelity. And it felt like, not in the moment, I didn’t know what the hell what was going on in the moment. When I looked back on it, it felt like there was a distinct rhythm to that time, which was first it was just utter pain and shock. Than there was this waiting time where the shock started to wear off and I actually had to do something.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Right? It’s like the pain as your house falls down, the house you’re living in falls down, and then waiting is like, now I have to, brick by brick, start building. And then there’s this third phase that is the rising, where you look at this new house you are forced to build, that you never wanted to build and you’re like, Oh, shit. This house is even better than the house I lived in before. It’s almost like it was all necessary to have a more beautiful life. And then this is rhythm of life.
Glennon Doyle:
I think in my first book I wrote about it as Easter. It’s like, Good Friday is the pain, and then Saturday is the waiting, and then Sunday, Easter Sunday, is the rising. It’s like fall, winter, spring; dusk, night, dawn. This pattern of growth is built into the rhythms of science and religion and all of it. So to discuss this life rhythm, our dearest, fiercest Jen Hatmaker is back. Jen, of you haven’t listened … not you, Jen, the pod squad. Please go back to episode 86, Jen Hatmaker, What We Win When We Lose It All. If you haven’t listened, you must listen to that. In that episode, Jen discusses the sudden implosion of her marriage, the pain, but what we didn’t get to in that episode was the waiting and the rising, about what happens after the life you built implodes and when you have no other chance but to painstakingly build it back.
Glennon Doyle:
So Jen Hatmaker is the New-York Times bestselling author of For The Love, and Fierce, Free and Full of Fire, along with 12 other books. She hosts the award-winning For the Love podcast, so freaking good, so helpful, is the delighted curator of the Jen Hatmaker Book Club and leader of a tightly knit online community where she reaches millions of people each week. Jen is a co-founder of the Legacy Collective, a giving organization that grants millions of dollars towards sustainable projects around the world. She is mom to five kids, and lives just outside Austin, Texas. Jen Hatmaker, thank you for coming back. We love you so much.
Jen Hatmaker:
So much, same. Hello, darlings. And worth noting is that I would like your listening community to know that we have full intention to squeeze all this into one podcast. What we said was, let’s do the rhythm, and then rising, and we’re going to do it and it’ll be an episode.” We got approximately one-tenth into it and went, we’re out of damn time. Like, “What happened here?,” because the four of us are verbose.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes, and we have a lot of pain. And we have a lot of pain.
Jen Hatmaker:
We have a lot of pain. It’s a lot of content.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
We had a lot of material. [crosstalk 00:03:45] Everyone was like, “Oh yeah, me too.” Like, “Also in my… ” We had so much to say.
Glennon Doyle:
Exactly.
Jen Hatmaker:
So thank you for round two. Let’s get to the rest of it. Let’s get to the good stuff.
Glennon Doyle:
Let’s do it. Okay, so set the scene for us first, if there’s anybody who has not listened to the first one. But tell us what… because everybody has something like this.
Jen Hatmaker:
Oh, that’s right.
Glennon Doyle:
I think it’s what happens in your 40s or your … maybe, I don’t know when it happens, but where the rug just, woosh, gets pulled out from under you. So what was yours?
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s Right. Really, for all four of us, we understand this in the context of marriage, that was we share this particular story of a disintegration, a catastrophic season of loss and then a rebuild. This is a very, very common story arc, just fill it in. It could be health, it could be your career. It could be other relationships that follow this rhythm. As you said, it’s mimicked in science, in our poetry, in our religious texts. We pin it to the board with marriage, but I think our listeners can go, “Oh yeah, me too; different story, same trajectory.”
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
For me it looked like the end of a 26 year marriage. And so I got married literally as a child. I was 19, couldn’t even drink on my own wedding. Not that we would’ve in the Baptist Fellowship Hall, okay? That’s a no, that’s a slippery slope right there. The glass of wine, the next thing you know, you’re clapping in church.
Glennon Doyle:
You know how much Jesus’s hated wine.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh, and Jesus hated that stuff.
Glennon Doyle:
Jesus was always hated talking about how we shouldn’t drink wine, wasn’t he?
Jen Hatmaker:
Oh, he hated parties. He’s like, “Don’t gather and celebrate. No, not on my watch.” And so I was married literally my entire adult life. I didn’t have a single second of adulthood in which I was not a part of a marriage, a one part of a couple. And then right at the beginning of the pandemic in July 2020, I lost my marriage overnight. So not so much of a slow loss, although to some degree and in our first conversation around this, to some degree it was, but that wasn’t something I was willing to admit at the time. I wasn’t willing to admit the erosion as it was happening, but the actual finale of it was overnight.
Jen Hatmaker:
And so, one day I was married and the next day I wasn’t and I was in a house by myself and we never shared a house again after that day. And we had five kids, at the time, they were 14 to 22. They were in this complicated space of being teens and young adults. And then of course in my world, as a leader, as a writer, as a speaker, a person who’s visible, fairly visible, at least in my world, I had spent a great deal of my adult energy centering a lot of my work around marriage and family. And that was incredibly disorienting to all of a sudden not be a wife and having had lost a marriage, one that I had championed, right? And so it’s been a two year process almost on the dot, two years and four days.
Glennon Doyle:
Wow. That’s right, four days.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah, two years and four days. Isn’t it funny how our body knows those dates? Do you all have that?
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
Do you have any dates where even if your brain is not paying attention to the calendar, your body starts being weird? It remembers.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
It just remembers. I noticed last week I was like, “What’s wrong with my blood pressure?” So this has been that story of recovery, honestly.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
And then the audacity to rebuild, which still feels a little audacious.
Glennon Doyle:
The recovery and the audacity to rebuild. Okay, so let’s talk about the recovery, the waiting, right? So, did you have a moment where you actually remember understanding that you had moved from the pain and shock and awe period to the rebuilding period? The brick by brick, what did that look like and feel like for you? The trudging. I remember that time with you, but what do I do next? Because when you’re a mom, you also don’t have any choice.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right. I would say that for me, I don’t think there’s any one path through recovery, by the way. So for everybody listening, this isn’t a template. Grief is its own deal and it will do what it wants in our bodies, and it affects us differently. In my experience, it came a little bit more in waves. And so at the beginning it was just a tsunami, an endless, relentless pressing you up against the wall, drowning in debris. There’s no escape, you’re going to die. You are going to die. This is going to get you. You cannot fight for the surface for one more second. The tsunami will take you out. And then in my experience, it began to ebb and flow a little bit.
Jen Hatmaker:
I would notice all of a sudden I would have an afternoon where I felt genuine joy and I laughed and I didn’t have a single bad thought for 49 minutes. And I was like, “I just did 49 minutes. That’s my longest stretch. Let’s write it down.” It was growing toward me, this sense of stability. And I was just pulling my way on a rope bit by bit. If I were going to do it from a higher level, I would say right around the year mark is when I thought I’m going to live. That’s when I knew at the year mark I’m past survival and I am going to thrive, but it took every single second of that year, every single second.
Glennon Doyle:
What did it look like? What did the rebuilding mean? You’re sitting there in the rubble, you were a wife, you are a mom of this little nuclear family. I think it’s so funny we call it nuclear family and we never talk about nuclear things are really dangerous and always explode, by the way.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Anyway. So yes, nuclear can go either way, right? So talk to us about what that looked like. What did you have to learn? What did you have to rebuild? The logistical things.
Jen Hatmaker:
Oh, man. Oh, man. At first the question on the table was, “How do I get through the fucking day?” That’s it. How do I manage a 24 hour period? The awake part and God in heaven, the sleep part. The sleep part was a nightmare. Don’t you remember?
Amanda Doyle:
Yes, and then you wake up in the morning and have to still remember it every morning that it was true.
Jen Hatmaker:
A nightmare. So right at the very beginning, y’all, Brene called me. This was before I had even said in public what was going on, what had happened. I was notably and visibly rattled and weird. Publicly something was wrong, but I hadn’t yet said, and somehow she knew. And so she texts me and she’s like, I have one hour, I’m going to call you. Do you have one hour? And when Brene asked you that you just clear the deck. And so we got on the phone and she said, here’s what you’re going to do to survive. So this was survival. This was stage one.
Jen Hatmaker:
She said, number one, you need to take absolute radical care of your body, radical. This is your number one priority. She goes, I know you don’t think this. I know that you don’t think this is your number … this is it. You’re going to take radical care of your body. You’re only going to eat good food. You are going to drink this much water a day. I think she gave it to me in ounces. You’re not going to drink. You are going to start moving your body every single day. I don’t care what you do, if it’s yoga, if it’s … I don’t care what you do, you’re going to move your body every single day. You are going to figure out a way to sleep at night. So if that means you’ve got to go to your doctor and get help sleeping, whatever it means, you are going to give your body sleep, and you’re going to meditate. I’d never meditated.
Glennon Doyle:
Are you meditating now? Do you meditate now?
Jen Hatmaker:
I still do it. It was so monumental. I didn’t know. And then she’d told me, which I talked to you guys about this last time, but she was like, right this second you’re going to order the book Codependent No More by Melody Beattie and that’s going to be your Bible.
Glennon Doyle:
Yep.
Jen Hatmaker:
And that’s what you’re going to read, and that’s what you’re going to start filling your brain with. And I did all that, I did what she said. Number one, because I’m scared of her.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
And number two, it felt smart. And so those very primal measures. I mean, we’re just in the bones and the guts of the thing, right?
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
We’re not talking about how to rebuild your finances yet. We’re not talking about how to make a new power of attorney.
Glennon Doyle:
Right.
Jen Hatmaker:
We’re talking about, here’s how you breathe. This is the way that you breathe. This is the way that you drink water. I credit her intervention in my life with giving me some first steps to hang onto and just to survive the tsunami, find a way to stay on the surface. That was at the beginning, just to stabilize my body a little bit because our body tells us what’s going on. My body fell apart. Did y’all have physical symptoms?
Glennon Doyle:
Jen, I never talk about this publicly, but before I found out about the infidelity, I was in bed for a year with an autoimmune disease.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Who knows? I’m just saying, that’s weird that my body was like, there’s some poison here and we don’t know what it is and we’re shutting down.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yes.
Glennon Doyle:
Then I moved to Florida to heal that and that’s when it all came out.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right.
Glennon Doyle:
The body, it’s wild.
Jen Hatmaker:
Well, I think our bodies were trying to tell us. And if we don’t give them the attention they deserve and need, if we don’t pay attention to what’s … all our body is trying to say is, you’re in danger, girl.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
Right, like ghosts.
Glennon Doyle:
Exactly.
Jen Hatmaker:
Molly, you’re in danger, girl. You’re in trouble, man.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
You may not want to admit this, but we see it clearly.
Amanda Doyle:
And we spend all of our times trying to tell our bodies, will you please sh-sh. We have all these things we need to do. It’s just, it’s important that we’ll get to you. We’ll get to you, one minute, body. And so all of those things that she was telling you were really just ways to make sure the voice came in louder, so that you could hear it, right? I heard that during that period, you started to refer to your body as she or her as opposed to it. What do you think that did for you?
Jen Hatmaker:
I didn’t invent this. I learned this from Dr. Hillary McBride. She’s one of my best teachers in terms of embodiment. Embodiment is new to me. That’s a new idea. I don’t think any of us grew up being taught how to be deeply in tune with our bodies or that our bodies … Right? I wasn’t, were you?
Glennon Doyle:
No, I was brought up to kick my body’s ass and keep it in control.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right.
Glennon Doyle:
And not let it get the best of me.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right. Damn her, like she’s just our enemy.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
I just always thought that my body was just an unfortunate container carrying around my brain.
Amanda Doyle:
A thing, not even a her, it. It is bothering me. I don’t like it.
Jen Hatmaker:
I don’t like it.
Glennon Doyle:
Right.
Jen Hatmaker:
And then of course you guys who know, I got to layer on a faith layer of oppression onto my body, which also said, in addition to this not looking right or being right, ever, ever, I was also taught that literally everything about my body, my instincts, my gut, my inner sense of knowing something, is untrustworthy.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
Right? Like.
Glennon Doyle:
Lean not on your own understanding, lean not.
Jen Hatmaker:
The heart is deceitful among all else. Who can trust it? That’s literally words out of the Bible, and I believe that. And so I thus thought if I like it, if I sense it, if I want it, if I prefer it, if I know it, if I suspect it, none of that can be trusted.
Glennon Doyle:
No.
Jen Hatmaker:
So thus it steered me into dangerous waters simply because I was picking the opposite of what my body was telling me, because I thought that was called faithfulness. And so that is a hell of a thing to overcome and reverse. And so embodiment is new for me, and Hillary McBride, and her PhD work is all around this and it’s so profound. And she’s the one who said, why don’t you start calling your body a she and a her? Because she is you. That isn’t separate from your brain and from your heart and soul, that is you. Your body is you. And she is team you and only team you, and her only agenda in this entire world is to keep you safe and flourishing. That’s it. She is looking out for you. She won’t tell you a lie. She will tell you what’s true.
Jen Hatmaker:
Now you may not listen to her. That I can attest to because I can look backwards and go, well, I didn’t know. And we talked about this in our first episode, but yes, I did. Yeah, I did. I didn’t want to know. I didn’t admit to knowing. I pretended like I didn’t. I told myself a new story, but my body actually did tell me all along, wake up.
Glennon Doyle:
Same.
Jen Hatmaker:
And so I started referring to my body as a she and as a her, and I talk to her in the most loving of ways, and I think of her as my best friend. This is my best friend. I don’t know if I can trust anybody in the whole world. I can trust her.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
I can trust my body. And when she tells me something, I’m going to be like, I’m going to listen to you. I’m going to pay attention to your wisdom, knowing that that is the highest good for my life. It’s still hard. I don’t know. How are you guys overcoming your problematic relationship with your bodies? Not just the way they look, but who they are.
Glennon Doyle:
I’m done with mine. I feel like I’m done with that, and I’m over it. I’m past it. Jen, how am I overcoming it?
Jen Hatmaker:
Congratulations.
Glennon Doyle:
As everybody here knows, I will pass this question to other people on this podcast who are a little better at this. It is the battle of my life. It is the confusing thing of my life. So when you’re saying these things, I’m listening to you and I feel like I’m hearing it for the first time. It’s the most beautiful revolutionary thing I’ve ever heard. I don’t know why it always feels like a brand new idea to me.
Jen Hatmaker:
You’ve always been honest about this and I appreciate it.
Glennon Doyle:
Oh.
Jen Hatmaker:
I appreciate you saying this is my crucible. I understand that. I understand the biggest mountain we each have to climb. And I appreciate you being honest and not making this tidy for everybody who listens to you. There hasn’t been a single message we’ve ever received since the day we were born that wants us to know this, right? Nobody, nobody. There’s a lot of benefits to us hating ourselves.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
And so there’s an enormous financial incentive for us to continue to hate ourselves. We have to fight for this one.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
We have to claw and fight our way to victory on this exact thing.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
And so I really appreciate honesty.
Amanda Doyle:
I had to catch my breath when I heard you say all of your work around recovery, including with your body is to believe what I know. And for me that feels like the final stage. Of course, I have this body dysmorphia and all the physical things. But that made me think how much do I actually … the voices, I try to keep that on the side of not knowing.
Glennon Doyle:
Well, because we know with our body and we believe with our head.
Amanda Doyle:
Right, right. So I guess I was just thinking about that a lot of, am I actually believing what I know? Am I willing to receive that message enough to believe it? And then I think the final frontier for me is how do I distinguish between what I know, what I’m feeling, and then either my trauma or anxiety response? What is a knowing message? And what is a message that is a trauma response that I’m like, I hear you telling me that. And that’s because you don’t feel safe, but you actually can feel safe in this situation. That for me is the trickiest final frontier. When I feel something, is that just me overly protecting myself because of this trauma or rightfully protecting myself?
Glennon Doyle:
It’s like Brittany Packnet Cunningham just tweeted, is it my intuition or my anxiety?
Amanda Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
I see what you’re saying.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah, right? We don’t want to have an overdeveloped fear response, which is possible too. I think the distinction is it’s a tricky needle to thread. I can occasionally give this maybe a 50% fail rate, but I can occasionally discern the difference by noticing at what point is that response rising up? Sometimes, not always because sometimes it’s correct, but sometimes in the moment, when that whole trigger thing goes off and our systems go into overdrive and our adrenaline starts surging all those trauma responses to keep us safe. Sometimes whatever I’m thinking in that moment bears a second glance simply because my body is over responding. I tend to be able to trust my instincts a little bit more when they come to me in the quiet of my own mind.
Glennon Doyle:
Ah.
Amanda Doyle:
Ah.
Jen Hatmaker:
You know what I mean? When I’m not, I’m not in fight or flight. I’m quietly in my life and my brain says, we know something, my body, we know something here. You know it, let’s examine this. This is a thing worth paying attention to. That tends to be a more trustworthy message. Although occasionally that fight or flight response is also right. It is also saying run, run for the hills. It’s a little bit of the next morning. Now what is my body telling me?
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
So when it’s a one on one conversation between you and you, it’s most trustworthy and intimate. When it might be a conversation involving extra people to whom you’re reacting, maybe a little bit less trustworthy.
Jen Hatmaker:
Well, I have what some people call a history of melodrama and it is possible. It is possible that I occasionally over respond once in a blue moon.
Glennon Doyle:
So Jen, I have a question for you about this. This just came to me. I remember in the early, early days of our friendship. I have no idea what happened. I can only guess what happened based on the fact that we got to this conversation, but I think my feelings got hurt about something. I’m just guessing based on my whole life, okay? And then we had a conversation and you were like, here’s the deal? I’m not a sensitive person.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right.
Glennon Doyle:
You and me are going to just have to learn about each other, because I am not a sensitive person. And I just remember being like, what does that mean? Wow. Oh, okay. And I have learned that from you. I know what you meant by that over time, right? Is there anything about this process that has made you more sensitive in terms of like … because sensitive can mean, I will not sense that thing.
Jen Hatmaker:
Oh yeah. That’s right.
Glennon Doyle:
I have a shell outside. I will not sense that thing, will carry on.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Is there any part of this … would you amend that at all? Because I’m actually trying to be less a little bit, a little bit. Right? Less.
Amanda Doyle:
So, do you think you’re sensitive now or do you think you were sensitive then and just didn’t recognize it?
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right. That’s a really good question and an interesting observation. That armor was a part of the way that I denied all kinds of things that I knew, that I sensed literally, but I didn’t want to. I didn’t want to sense that. I don’t want to sense that. I don’t want that to be how it is. I don’t want that to be true. I want that to fit the way that I wanted it to fit. And so thus I would choose desensitization toward it. Literally, I will not sense this in the way that I should. Some of this is Enneagram three stuff. It is my instinct to prop up. It’s just my instinct to be like, this is better than it actually is. I’m not sensitive to the nuance of what’s complex here or what is in trouble here because I want it to be shiny. I love shiny.
Amanda Doyle:
And I can will it to work. I can will this to work. I can take my efficacy, apply it to this situation and victorious we will be. You, too.
Jen Hatmaker:
And Amanda, we can.
Amanda Doyle:
Yes. That’s the problem, that’s the problem.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s the problem. We sure as shit can.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
And so I appreciate the observation, Glennon, and part of my recovery process and really rebuilding is that that armor didn’t really serve me. I thought it was at the time, but I can look back on it and see that that actually hurt a lot of people, not just me. That was not at all in service to my marriage. Think about being married to somebody who’s impervious, who has an armor up at all time, who is self-reporting not sensitive. And you are trying to crack through. You are sending up warning flares everywhere, that there’s a disconnection happening and something is not great and this is not tracking and we are off. And then your partner is so committed to the narrative, so committed to the shiny version of the story that isn’t even real, you can’t even get through to her. You can’t even get her to engage what’s real.
Jen Hatmaker:
Guess what? That’s hard to be married to. That would be really hard to be in a relationship with, period. And so this is something that I have learned about myself through counseling and that I’ve also done with my kids, this armored mom who can always just power us through the thing. It actually makes people feel lonely. That makes them feel alone in their feelings, in their response to something. It makes them feel unheard because they are. They are unheard because my quick response is, this is fine. It’s not as bad as you think it is. What a lonely person to be partnered to. So me dropping some of that shield and learning how to be sensitive to my environment, to my relationships, to my own inner voice is new. It’s new work for me and I wouldn’t call it easy for me.
Jen Hatmaker:
I think it’s hard. It’s hard. I cry a lot. I don’t like that. I don’t like that. I feel my feelings a lot. I don’t like them, so it’s not like I’m just going, this feels great. Now I’m way more of a feeling person in the world. I think it’s bullshit, it’s hard. And then, because I’m not practiced at it too, I’m like, is this an appropriate response? Is it okay for my feelings to be hurt right now?
Glennon Doyle:
Ah.
Jen Hatmaker:
You know what I mean? Is it okay for me to be bothered by this? Does this mean everything’s doomed? Because that’s my old narrative. If something’s wrong, it’s all wrong, it’s ruined. It’s ruined, but where’s the redemption. It’s broken, throw it away. Again, that I don’t have good practice here. And so having to be able to say this one thing can be addressed and no one’s going to die. We’re going to live. And maybe the thing will even be improved by a genuine conversation around it where you can say, this is the way that this is making me feel and I just wonder if we can talk about it. So anyway, I’m learning this.
Jen Hatmaker:
Literally, you guys, when I sit down with my counselor, Clarissa, I have to get a notebook in front of me and she will write me a script like I’m a kindergartner. She’ll be like, then what you can say is the way that this is making me feel … And I’m like, whoa, wait, what comes after that? I’ll write it down like a movie script. So I’m literally having to learn language around it, but it’s hard. Will I get better? I don’t know.
Glennon Doyle:
It’s so beautiful.
Abby Wambach:
You will. I mean, here’s the thing. I feel like with all this conversation about sensitivity, I think what we’re trying to figure out, especially women who either choose to armor or women who are an open gaping wound, I think it’s really important that the goal isn’t just to feel for feeling sake. It’s like, Hey, I need to embody this sensitivity to sense my surroundings so that I can learn how to manage those feelings and the world around me and have it be this symbiotic relationship with our environments, with our inner worlds. So that everybody, myself included, being the most important one, can actually evolve and grow. I think that sensitivity has a bad rap.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah, because it’s really self care.
Abby Wambach:
Yes.
Glennon Doyle:
We all talk about candles as self-care, but sensing what your brain is trying to tell you, what body’s trying to tell you and believing it, is really what self-care is.
Abby Wambach:
And then being able to manage it. I think that the word sensitivity has a real negative connotation because it’s like, oh, you’re sensitive. Like the world …
Glennon Doyle:
You’re going to fall apart.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
You’re going to fall apart.
Abby Wambach:
The world tells women, oh, if you’re too sensitive, then you’re a fucking woman and good luck.
Amanda Doyle:
Yeah.
Abby Wambach:
And it’s like, no, men also are sensitive, but they armor themselves and that gives themselves a whole slew of problems. It’s about managing the sensing that we have.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s good.
Amanda Doyle:
And also paying attention to why.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
I think in some ways, when you’re talking about desensitization, Jen, I think some people come by it just from little bitty up, and then some people come by it as an adaptation to their situation. You might come to a relationship like that or you might become that in a relationship. If you’re not getting your needs met as your sensitive nature, you might gradually as a survival mechanism over time become desensitized because why would you keep those open if it’s never going to be met? Right?
Glennon Doyle:
True.
Amanda Doyle:
So I think it’s interesting to actually look at yourself and be like, okay, is this a chicken or an egg? Or is it both because it might be that I am now this hard and desensitized person, but that actually might be what I’ve been doing in this relationship to survive it.
Abby Wambach:
Interesting.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s a great point. That’s some deep diving right there, to go back and find a version of yourself earlier to see, wait, has this always been the case or did I used to be a different way? Did I used to perceive the world differently? Did I used to receive information differently? And did I armor up just to keep going? That’s a great point. And maybe it’s a little of both.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
But I could actually see a little bit of both in me. I think one thing that we touched on last time, this was a part of my rebuilding was this whole truth that … because I like y’all. I could point to these things that went wrong in the marriage and just say that was the problem. And I could be right. People would sign off on that.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah. Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
They’d be like, oh yeah, you’re right.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yep.
Amanda Doyle:
You are absolved.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s it. That’s a tidy story. But the truth is that however I was operating inside my marriage either by hook or by crook, whether it was a way that I just … it’s my instinct that I’ve got to work to improve or it’s a response either way, it doesn’t really matter. If I don’t pay honest attention to my own patterns, my own responses, my own way of assimilating information, my own way of relating, that’s my problem.
Abby Wambach:
Yep.
Jen Hatmaker:
I will walk that shit right into the next thing.
Abby Wambach:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
And I’m frankly already walking it into all my other relationships as a friend, as a sister, as a mom. And so that, I don’t care for. I don’t care for this information that this, this, this, this, and this are my problems.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
I don’t love that, but either I pay attention to that or I’m going to find myself repeating the exact same catastrophic relationship.
Abby Wambach:
That is right.
Amanda Doyle:
That’s fascinating because I think we often, well, you’re just going to repeat it in your next relationship if you don’t deal with it now, but you’re saying even with your relationship with your kids or your friends.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
What’s an example of the way that those relationships outside of romantic relationships have improved or disintegrated because of this new self that you’re bringing forward to them?
Jen Hatmaker:
Okay. Well as a mom, I think we touched on this, but my new fresh understanding of codependency has absolutely characterized the way I’ve parented in that my preference is to do everything in my power to manage outcomes for my kids. I want to control their behavior. I want to control the results. I want to make things easier for them. I want to clean up some of their messes, and some of this is altruistic and some of it isn’t. Some of it is that I want this to look better than it is.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Abby Wambach:
That’s good.
Jen Hatmaker:
Turns out kids are a mess.
Glennon Doyle:
They’re just the worst.
Jen Hatmaker:
They’re the worst and so were we.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Abby Wambach:
Yep.
Jen Hatmaker:
They’re not any better than we were.
Glennon Doyle:
No, which is tragic.
Jen Hatmaker:
They’re doing all the same shit we did.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
It’s just that we know about it because of Instagram.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
Right? That’s the problem. It’s just, they could be less sneaky than we were. In fact, my best friends are here right now with me. They got here yesterday, in Minnesota where I’m at. And they were telling us that the youngs, that’s what we call them. We all have all these youngs, all of our kids are in their twenties and teens. The Youngs were telling them about this new app. I can’t with a new apps. I really can’t, somebody deliver us. But there’s a new one called Be Real.
Glennon Doyle:
Oh, yep. We know it.
Jen Hatmaker:
Do you about this?
Glennon Doyle:
Yep. Yep. Yep.
Jen Hatmaker:
Back and front. That’s it. Abby, front, back, one second of a day. It’s just a one day thing. And my girlfriend Jenny said, Caleb, that’s my middle son, he’s 20, she’s like, Be Real came up for me that said, Hey, you may want to be friends with Caleb Hatmaker. And she’s like, and I didn’t say yes. You know why? I don’t want to see him being real. No, I don’t. I want no realness.
Glennon Doyle:
No.
Jen Hatmaker:
I don’t want real.
Glennon Doyle:
No.
Jen Hatmaker:
I think I know what it is and I don’t want it.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
And so I was doing this thing with my kids, the way that I was structuring parenting, where I would not let the chips fall where they may. I would let the chips fall on my plate. I would pick up all the chips, stack them. It’s no good. It’s no good.
Glennon Doyle:
It’s no good. It is Jenga. I wonder about this with you because there’s a certainty that religion can give us a certainty or our stories about marriage. You said you were championing marriage. I for one actually think you’re actually a real example of marriage now. Right? I think you’re probably a stronger teacher about marriage than ever before, because it’s all real and … but my question is, I remember when I had to tell the kids that I was getting divorced. It was awful to tell them that, but the reason it was so awful is because I actually remember three months before Tish looking at me and saying, promise me you’ll never get divorced. And my answer to her was, yeah, I’ll never get divorced.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
We talk about children only understand story. My story to them was our family is not like other families. And I wouldn’t have used those words, but you’re safe.
Jen Hatmaker:
Okay.
Glennon Doyle:
We are special.
Jen Hatmaker:
Sure.
Glennon Doyle:
And so it was taking away the narrative that I had given them about world order, about the way being human is that was the most shattering. And I just wonder how have your stories changed with the kids? Because were I able to do it over again, were I able to like tell anyone right now who’s raising little ones, it would’ve been, we are a group of people who are going to love each other one way or another forever.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
But the thing about life is we never know what things are going to look like. Do you know what I’m saying?
Jen Hatmaker:
Totally.
Glennon Doyle:
Presenting a different narrative with more nuance and what ifs and less certainty so that when something happens, it doesn’t feel like you’re pulling that Jenga thing out and the whole thing’s falling. It’s actually more safe. It’s more [crosstalk 00:39:28] safe. Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
I didn’t have even access to that true story before. I wouldn’t have allowed myself to think that or know it or believe it, or certainly communicate it. Even all evidence to the contrary, I would still and was still saying, everybody’s safe. You are tucked into our little nest. The nest will never, ever be compromised, and I thought it. I mean, I really believed that. And so I think there’s … this is an interesting conversation to have with the happily marrieds, or more true, not necessarily the happily marrieds, but the ones pretending to be.
Glennon Doyle:
Right.
Jen Hatmaker:
Whatever you are, the marrieds, if you want to give it a big … the marrieds. I’m trying to go back to being married Jen and think how I would’ve received what you just said as a married person. Would I have been able to recognize the wisdom of what you just said or what I’ve been so committed to the thing that I’ve been like, not here, not this zip code. But you’re right, because none of us are exceptional. I’m telling you, none, nobody. Nobody is impervious to loss, to change, to trauma finally rearing its ugly head. None, zero. There’s no protection, none. There isn’t one. And so I think that story told to families, I think it would provide a weird sideways comfort that really, no matter what happens, you will be loved. We will love each other. We will still belong to one another in this world [crosstalk 00:41:31] no matter what the arrangement looks like.
Abby Wambach:
Yes.
Glennon Doyle:
And like faith, religion, what we know is there is a force that loves ,,, whatever it is. And holidays, I was like, there’s a Santa Claus and I will die on this mountain. What? Then growing up just becomes a series of things your parents lied to you about.
Abby Wambach:
Isn’t that so weird that we all accept that and then we do it to our own kids?
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah. I remember telling Chase about Santa Claus and him going, oh, is that the thing about … is that true about God too?
Jen Hatmaker:
Totally.
Glennon Doyle:
And I was like, shit, I don’t fucking know. Let’s just. No one teaches us what to do, Chase.
Abby Wambach:
We don’t know what we’re doing.
Glennon Doyle:
We’re just doing the best.
Jen Hatmaker:
Just let us be a parent.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah, exactly. It was a bad call on somebody’s part.
Jen Hatmaker:
Totally.
Glennon Doyle:
Like gender, this category of things blows my mind constantly and I don’t understand what it is, so I don’t have any answer to this. I’m just asking you.
Jen Hatmaker:
Okay.
Glennon Doyle:
What is forgiveness? Is it real? Is it a decision? Is it a feeling?
Amanda Doyle:
Is it like Santa Claus?
Glennon Doyle:
Is it like Santa Claus is what we want to … Is it stability in terms of, it’s not real?
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
What is forgiveness to you? What’s your version of it? Do you have it with your ex? What is the situation?
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s a big one.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah. I’ve thought about this a lot and had to pick my way through it too, because as with anything, as with all of this, as with both recovery and rebuilding, I’m responsible for me, that’s it. I am responsible for me. I am not responsible for what someone else does, says, thinks, chooses. I’m not responsible. I am responsible for my words, my responses, what I decide to believe, what I decide to hang onto, what I decide to release. That’s all mine. And so it’s not true that we’re always powerless, that we are just at the whims of what somebody else does to us. It feels that way for a minute, it does. It’s tempting to lean into a victim model because also that plays better because it’s easy to be sympathetic toward a victim. It’s easy to rally the troops to your side. It’s just neater. It’s neater and it lacks nuance. And I that’s my favorite thing, I love it. Can it just be completely black and white where I am the hero? I love that story.
Jen Hatmaker:
Forgiveness falls in this camp. This is mine. This is entirely mine to sort out. I can just tell you that for me, there’s a minute where unforgiveness is my choice and I want to choose it. I’m choosing it on purpose because it feels good. It’s keeping my adrenaline active. It’s keeping me vigilant when I feel like, oh, this lack of vigilance, look what you got for it. This is a fucking mess.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
You’re going to have to pick up every one of these shattered pieces and figure out what to do them by yourself.
Abby Wambach:
That’s good.
Jen Hatmaker:
So you’re pissed, you are that’s how I’m going to be. And for a minute that feels self protective and maybe it is, frankly, maybe it is. I’m learning to not be super judgemental toward every iteration of myself in this process. That it isn’t just the one thing, that our reactions can run the gamut and it doesn’t make them right or wrong. It just makes them what we needed that day. But for me, unforgiveness, which its cousins are like resentment and bitterness, fury. There’s a place for fury. There’s a place for all that, frankly. But after a minute it’s so corrosive to my insides.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
I can’t live like it. I can’t, I just can’t. I cannot live like that in the world. I cannot walk around in righteous fury in my brain every second. I cannot walk around bitter. It’s not my way. It feels bad in my bones. And I notice that every thought, I’m constantly writing dialogue and rebuttals and I’m tidying up the story by the way. I’m shining up my parts of it.
Glennon Doyle:
Totally.
Jen Hatmaker:
Right? I’m absolutely coming out better than I was, just give me time. Every month it gets a little better. Right? It’s like I can polish it and I do. And then I just start to feel so out of alignment, do you know what I mean?
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
And it feels bad and I don’t like it. And so the worst thing about forgiveness to me, it’s so very helpful when that person is genuinely sorry, that’s helpful. Why can’t that be the system, right? Why can’t that be the system? But the truth is forgiveness has absolutely nothing to do with that other person.
Abby Wambach:
That’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
Not one thing, not one thing. It doesn’t require their anything, not their participation. We don’t have to sign off on the same version of the thing. We don’t need an I’m sorry, although I did receive that, but we don’t need … that’s not it.
Amanda Doyle:
Right.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s bonus, that’s bonus content. Forgiveness is an inside job. And it just is me deciding that in letting somebody else off the hook, I’m really letting myself off the hook. I really am. Ugh, God, I can just exhale. I can lay the whole thing down. It’s so heavy. It’s so heavy to carry all that around every day and keep hoisting it up and just, Ugh, God, it’s exhausting, so exhausting.
Amanda Doyle:
That clicked something for me, when you said it’s right after, where it’s useful. It’s like the unforgiveness and the rage and the fury is an engine.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
It’s like an energetic engine to get you through those periods where you really do. You’re looking at all the shattered glass and you are like, I need some fuel to start putting this back together, because if you don’t use that fuel, if you don’t have the unforgiveness and the rage, then all you have is just catastrophic sadness.
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right.
Amanda Doyle:
Those are the only two options you have then. And catastrophic sadness is not an energetic system.
Glennon Doyle:
Right. Right.
Jen Hatmaker:
No, no, no.
Amanda Doyle:
So how are you going to do the pieces? But once you get through that initial period where you need that engine to drive you, to keep you on autopilot, then that energetic system is going somewhere. It’s no longer outside of you. It’s inside of you.
Jen Hatmaker:
Wow.
Amanda Doyle:
And it’s just living in you when you don’t need it anymore to get through the thing you need to do. And that’s when it starts to do.
Glennon Doyle:
Corrode, because that’s still an energy. And by the way, it’s not just to get you through, it’s to get you safe again. I feel strongly about that. The anger and the fury is useful when it helps you reset the boundary that made you unsafe. So the first time I ever felt safe around Craig, I’ve said this before, was in the elevator. Well, the first time I felt whatever the hell forgiveness is, is in the elevator after our divorce mediation, because I finally was like, oh, I made myself safe again. I did the thing where I can’t be hurt in this exact same way anymore.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
So I do think that trying to find forgiveness when you are still completely as vulnerable to the person who hurt you is cart before the horse thing. Maybe the anger and fury is to help us rebuild the boundary, but then after that boundary’s built, it’s just poison.
Jen Hatmaker:
I like that. That’s my experience. That is my exact experience. And I think there’s so much compassion for women who are in the anger, fury, adrenaline space and to use it for what it’s there for. That’s our body’s response on purpose. That’s a biological response for a reason.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
It is useful. There is a place for it, but I think we can feel when the scales start tipping, right? When all of a sudden, I’m just starting to feel like a hateful person and that’s not my nature. It’s metastasizing. I don’t want it. I don’t want it. I don’t want to go down like that. And so at that point it is work. It is work to put the breaks on and to begin to choose healing, because that to me, that’s the moment when I tip from survival to healing. And which one do I want to pick?
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
And I picked healing and part of healing is forgiveness, it just is. You can’t have both. These don’t coexist well. You can’t heal while you are absolutely black hearted resentful.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
You know what I mean? You just can’t.
Glennon Doyle:
And you say … because people think of it as it should. But what’s interesting about what you’re saying over and over again is it doesn’t feel good. It goes back to what we talked about in the beginning, that it doesn’t feel good in my body. I don’t like it. I don’t like unforgiveness. Not because somebody told us we should forgive, but it doesn’t feel good. She doesn’t like it.
Amanda Doyle:
And nothing to do with what the other person deserves.
Glennon Doyle:
Right.
Amanda Doyle:
I think that’s the question. Does that person deserve to be forgiven is utterly irrelevant. It’s do you deserve and wish to carry this inside you?
Jen Hatmaker:
That’s right. It has nothing to do with what they’ve done or what they’re doing with it then. But what it will do if we don’t choose it, if we don’t choose forgiveness, it also truncates any further work we’re going to do on ourselves, because the longer I carry the story, which is, this is all your fault and you have harmed me and I am pissed, that is a block for me being able to genuinely and honestly face some of my own stuff. I just can’t do it. I can’t do both. It’s either all your fault or I get to also face my responses, my patterns. I can’t have both of those things and so I have to make this choice. Am I ready to move into the work that’s going to be required on my own heart and soul? And forgiveness is the front door to that moment, and I want that. I want that for me, it feels better. It feels better.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s shifting to me, that you hold onto it so you don’t have to do your own shift.
Abby Wambach:
That’s right. That’s exactly the word. I hate the word forgiveness, I honestly do. I just hate the word because it implies, I now trust this other person.
Jen Hatmaker:
Right.
Abby Wambach:
And that’s just not what I think of forgiveness. Forgiveness is all about personal work. I think of forgiveness as like, oh, I’m letting go of that old story. I’m letting go of that old wound. I’m not carrying that with me anymore. I actually don’t really believe that I’m going to ever trust somebody truly who’s wronged me in a serious way ever again. And that’s what think people assume forgiveness is. No, no, no. Forgiveness is about self. I think that, Jen, your reframe on that, that it’s not about somebody else is really … it’s beautiful.
Glennon Doyle:
Jen, we only have a couple minutes left, so I want to ask you this. So we all know the extraordinary Jenaissance that has happened over the last year, I guess, when we moved from the pain to the waiting and the rising. When you look at the house falls down, you build it brick by brick, have you had that moment yet where you look at your new house or your new life and think, huh, I don’t think I would trade any of this. You know that Mary Oliver quote that someone once gave me a box of darkness and it took me years to know that this too was a gift.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Does it feel that way or does that feel like horseshit?
Jen Hatmaker:
It feels a hundred percent true.
Glennon Doyle:
Ah.
Jen Hatmaker:
100% true. So much so that I feel shocked. I feel shocked by it. I made that shift over. This is what I have. What am I going to do with it? This is who I am. What am I going to do with her? I’m at the halfway point of my life, what do I want for the second half? So I went from management to vision. Do you know what I mean? I decided to build a new vision for my life. I wasn’t just going to manage trauma. I wasn’t just going to recover from suffering. I was moving into vision. What’s the vision for my life? I got a lot of gas left in the tank. That is when everything got exciting, and that is when I realized I am way more capable than I thought I was.
Jen Hatmaker:
I had phoned in big pieces of adulting inside marriage. I just handed it to another person to manage. Some of this is an ordinary division of labor inside a marriage. Some of it was laziness on my part. Some of it was this learned helplessness I had done. I don’t know what our bills are. I don’t know how much money I make. That’s dumb, I’m smart.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
I am smart. I am powerful. I make a lot of money. I have a big career. What am I doing? I’m not a dummy, but I was acting like one and that was an immature way to live. I don’t care if I had the happiest marriage in the whole world. Me absolutely checking out of enormous decisions in my adult life that affected our future, our kids, that’s that was irresponsible. So me now, guess what? I don’t get to do that anymore. Right? Jen, grow up. So me pulling up a seat to the table of adults and going, I’ve got to learn this. Guess what I am, good at it. I’m good at all of it. I am smart. I am responsible. I am forward thinking. I know how to save money. Guess what I do, I invest. Girls, I invest money.
Abby Wambach:
Oh, that’s right.
Jen Hatmaker:
I invest money in the stock market. I have a whole new vision for my life and it’s not just financial. I have a vision for work, for what I want to do. What do I want my fifties to look like? I know what I want my sixties to look like. I know what I want my seventies look like. You know why? I’ve charted it out. I made a vision.
Glennon Doyle:
Of course, you have.
Jen Hatmaker:
And I like shocked myself at what a good adult I am. I am such a good partner to myself. I am my best partner. Guess what? I will never let myself down, never, never. I will trust myself all the way in every direction. I am trustworthy. And so this bit of it, I just keep looking at myself, going, you were in there all along, Jen. It’s not like this is a new version of you. You’ve always been capable. You have always been wise. You’ve always been thoughtful. You just didn’t choose it. You didn’t choose those things in a lot of categories. And so being forced to choose a now, oh, hell. I’m just like, I feel so empowered and powerful in my own life now, so much so.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s recovery. That’s recovery. It’s recovering a version of yourself that you always were before you got all this stuff. It’s going back to the original plan for you. This was always you.
Jen Hatmaker:
I like that. Thank God.
Amanda Doyle:
Jen, does it ever freak you out? From where you sit right now, what you just described, this was always you. You were always in there. You can fully trust yourself. Does it ever freak you out to think back and think what if this wasn’t chosen for you? Because from where you were, it seems to me like it would be very, very unlikely that you would’ve chosen this for you.
Jen Hatmaker:
Totally.
Amanda Doyle:
So is it part of you in the oddest shit that could be possible feel lucky that it got chosen for you?
Jen Hatmaker:
Yes. Yes. When I tell you that, and I mean this, this is genuine, I wouldn’t pick the path to this moment, the way that it went down ever. I wouldn’t pick it. I wouldn’t pick it in this way. I wouldn’t have chosen this story. The way it went down, it was so much collateral damage, so painful for so many … I wouldn’t pick it. However, at this point in my life, I feel so lucky and so excited that I get to choose and write the second half of my life and it is mine. And guess what? I’m not a 19 year old bride this time. I’m about to turn 48. I’ve lived, I’ve learned, I’m smart, I’m wise. I’ve learned how to trust myself. I’ve learned how to trust my body, my instinct, my mind, my thoughts, my gut. I’ve wisely chosen my relationships at this point, though, they were on purpose, every last one of them.
Jen Hatmaker:
This is the best me I have ever been by a mile. And so now I just feel like I can trust the story I’m about to write. Do you know what I mean? I was a baby when I started writing the first one, so was Brandon. We were babies. We were doing the best we could with the weird little truncated story we’d been handed since we were born, right? We did the best we could with all we knew. But at this point, oh, my gosh, how exciting is this for me? Like and I’m not afraid. I’m just not afraid. I’m not afraid. Oh, this could happen again, or you could be betrayed in a … No, it won’t. No, it won’t. I know it will not. I would know in advance. I’m paying attention.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jen Hatmaker:
I’m eyes wide open in my world, in my life. I’m learning how to be sensitive, which means having conversations before they’re at level 10. That’s what that means, guys, at level one, at level one course correction. And then you’re just like, oh, and now it’s resolved? Okay. Okay.
Amanda Doyle:
I was just going to wait six months and just have to move.
Jen Hatmaker:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Okay, Jen, I need you to understand, out of all of the people in all of the land, you are just one of my favorite human beings to talk to in the world, in the world. You are so honest and so smart and so vibrant. And so I just love you so deeply. I loved old Jen and I love new Jen and I love whatever Jen is next. What you’re saying is like, it won’t happen again. Not because nobody else will betray you, who the hell knows, but because you won’t betray yourself.
Jen Hatmaker:
Never.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jen Hatmaker:
I’ll take my little self right into the next space.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s right.
Abby Wambach:
That’s right.
Glennon Doyle:
And to the rest of you, you don’t have a next right thing. Just freaking listen to this again. That’s your next right thing.
Jen Hatmaker:
I love you.
Abby Wambach:
Go be with your girls. We love you so much.
Amanda Doyle:
Love you so much.
Glennon Doyle:
We love you. Bye, everybody.