Is Biden In or Out? with Jessica Yellin
July 17, 2024
Amanda Doyle:
Welcome back to We Can Do Hard Things. We are in a time that is testing that theory. We are here to walk together with you through these very odd, scary, destabilizing times we are in and with us to do that, to help us understand what the hell is going on, what has been going on in the last few days, what is going on behind the scenes. What we can expect is our dear friend Jessica Yellin, she has been with us so many times and is always a very stable force of fact and trying to take it down a notch so we can stay grounded and know what to do next.
Jessica Yellin is the founder of News Not Noise, a pioneering Webby award-winning independent news brand. Over 1 million subscribers and followers across Instagram and other digital media rely on Jessica and News Not Noise to understand what matters, which experts to trust and to manage their information overload. She’s the former Chief White House correspondent for CNN and an Emmy and Gracie Award-winning political correspondent for ABC, MSNBC and CNN. Follow her on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook at Jessica Yellin, that’s Y-E-L-L-I-N. You could also find the new Not Noise Newsletter on Substack. Jessica, thank you. This is a crazy time and you have made time for us once again and we are grateful for it.
Jessica Yellin:
I’m so happy to be with you because I get some calm from you and I’m trying to do my best to stay centered, but I could use the community, so it’s great to see you.
Amanda Doyle:
We were just talking about how checking in to see how you were and we’re saying it feels like it’s a very Herculean task to take care of everything that needs to be taken care of right now. And so taking care of each other and ourselves feels very important. So we hope that everyone’s listening is taking care of themselves. And let’s just jump in, we had originally scheduled this conversation to try to understand what is happening in the Democratic Party in the Biden decision, whose decision it is, whether he stays or gets replaced. And in the few days since then, there was a shooting at Trump that is being referred to as an assassination attempt. The FBI has declared it that at one of his rallies, and so it brings front and center the violence of this time. And so let’s talk about that first, see what’s going on over there and in the convention with the new VP announcement for him, and then we’ll get into the Democrats, but I tell us what we know about what happened at the rally.
Jessica Yellin:
It’s also challenging to talk about because the minute I start to pursue one story, something else ginormous erupts and we change to the next thing. What happened at the rally, there was a really kind of inexplicable security breach. I can’t tell you how many Secret Service protected events I’ve attended in my career. And one of the most basic things is that the buildings in the immediate perimeter either have a sniper on top or have a guard at the door to ensure nobody can get to the roof, it’s just sort of 101. It’s a weird thing of political coverage. You get used to being in a place surrounded by snipers.
So first there was nobody protecting a roof that was just 400 feet from the stage and somehow gunman who was only 20 years old, was able to get off enough shots to kill one person, a firefighter and graze former president Trump’s ear. And he’s saying that because he turned his head in the moment before that shot was fired, he survived. Had he not turned his head, we would be having a very different conversation right now. So I mean we could talk about how did this happen, all the ask cover that’s come down after that. This kid like the FBI doesn’t know his motive. And I would just caution folks, remember Reagan was shot in 1981 by somebody who wanted to get an actresses attention. It isn’t always politically motivated.
Amanda Doyle:
And in fact what we know about him is that he was a registered Republican and that this would’ve been the first election that he was voting in. I’m saying this neither here nor there, he also apparently might’ve contributed $15 to a left leaning cause to. So there’s no basis on which to ascribe any motive at this point.
Jessica Yellin:
And he was not one of these people who had a big social media presence. He did not leave any manifesto, no rants. It’s a black hole right now. The FBI has been going through his phone and these are considered early days in an investigation, so we should know more soon, but sometimes you don’t know. And there were enough weird things that went down to make the internet go nuts with conspiracy theories.
Amanda Doyle:
Yes.
Jessica Yellin:
But also there’s no evidence supporting any of those theories either.
Amanda Doyle:
Right. And the impact, regardless of what it is, and I have been just FYI, have been admonished and encouraged by my illustrious co-hosts to keep this time with you based on only things that we can get from you because you are a very… Whereas I have an abundance of opinions, you have an abundance of facts. So I’m just going to say like asterisks when I have a half an hour that I could go down a rabbit hole of things. But what we do know is that this has the election insofar as there were immediate calls for unity, immediate calls for saying that this was Biden’s fault, saying that Biden pulled his ads against Trump during this time. So that has happened and in a way I think has quieted things in the Biden space.
Jessica Yellin:
In the Biden space, yeah. So there are a couple of dynamics. One is the kind of attention this is drawn to Trump and the boost it seems to be giving him as he entered the RNC is one point. There’s the sort of larger conversation about political language, which I think we should talk about. But to start with the conversation about Biden, this happened as the Democrats were in the middle of this sort of internal, I don’t know, you don’t want to call it a civil war, but this great deal of self-reflection about who should be the candidate at this point and is it too late to change? And immediately there was a lot of momentum and there was a lot that was going to happen over the weekend to push Biden out of the race. That all stopped and it gave Biden a lot of breathing room to sort of push himself further forward as the inevitable candidate. I will say that we’re speaking after Biden did his second interview with network news, he spoke to NBC. He didn’t do anything awful. There’s no terrible gaffe, but it was not a good interview and it has a lot of people who were his critics re-energized today and again trying to revive this effort to replace him on the ticket. So I think that’s going to start back up in the next few days to be honest.
Amanda Doyle:
Great. So let’s transition to that which is yes, we should be anti-hostility in our language and we should be pro-honesty also, which includes the reality that this violent political rhetoric has not only been not condemned by Trump, it has been fomented throughout this time. And I mean the truth is that yes, we need to be very aware to not personally villainize and make people targets and we also need to stay very much on target with what is true.
And what is true is that Trump has been fomenting this for a while and has not responded to tremendous acts of political violence that have happened over the last few years, including Paul Pelosi whose head was fractured with a hammer by an assailant who came into his home and did that to him. And in the days following that, Trump stood up and called Nancy Pelosi crazy and said that she was the only source of terror and said, “How’s her husband doing, anybody know?” To the entire place that was laughing at him while he was still in critical condition, he also refused to denounce the militia group that had a conspiracy to take Governor Gretchen Whitmer hostage and in the days following said that the people hated her and that she wanted to be a dictator. So this has been the kind of environment he’s been refusing to condemn until the moment that it affects him and it’s moreover politically expedient for him to make Democrats stop talking right now.
Jessica Yellin:
Yeah, I have plenty of examples of how it’s sort of a gaslight to say, “Oh, you need to call out threats to democracy when they’re there.”
Amanda Doyle:
Great, great, great, great. All right, so before all of this, is it going to be Biden? Is it not going to be Biden? Whose decision is this? Is it riskier to have him in or riskier to replace him? So where were we pre-shooting?
Jessica Yellin:
Oh, that’s a good question. So pre-shooting, there were these two camps inside the Democratic Party. There was the camp that said, “Biden is the candidate stick with Biden.” He is the only Democrat or person who has defeated Trump in politics. He has already won votes, his name is going on the ticket, his money is there, he has the campaign apparatus and it’s easier to stick with the guy you got than to risk a change at the last minute. In fact, some people are so adamant about that, that there’s a real growing sort of antipathy and kind of anger in the party. In my own community, people will yell at me and get very mad because I talk about Biden’s weaknesses and give air to the point of view that some people think it should be replaced. So there’s extreme infighting over this, but that’s over there.
The second camp that wants Biden to go. Let me just tell you, quote like David Plouffe who was Obama’s campaign manager and strategist. David Plouffe in my view is the most calm and sort of exceptional mind when it comes to gathering data, strategy and language and understanding all of that and seeing forward what could happen and what’s likely to happen. David Plouffe says, “The Democratic Party has never had this weak a candidate at the top of the ticket since 1988.” So the closest parallel is when Dukakis ran and Democrats had a terrible outcome that year. A lot of elected Democrats are fearful that if Biden’s at the top of the ticket voters will be so demoralized that Democrats will not just lose the White House but will also not regain the house and will also lose control of the Senate.
So what they see is Democrats losing all of government if Biden’s at the top of the ticket and their argument is there is still time to make a change. It is risky, yes, but it is worth it in their view. It’s kind of like that scene in a space movie where everybody’s on the deck of the spaceship and it says, “We’re about to crash, should we change to another ship?” And some people are like, “No, I don’t believe the dials, we’re not going to crash.” And other people are like, “We’re getting out because at least in a new ship we have a chance.” That’s kind of where the Democrats are.
Amanda Doyle:
And so yes, great, let’s just name the thing which is that we are not supposed to be talking about this. People who want to do everything they can to ensure there is not another Trump administration are not supposed to be talking about this. And I think it’s important just to say that part out loud because it feels to me like a very dysfunctional family. It feels like this idea that we cannot say what is wrong in our family because we are going to make the family look weak to the outside world, to the people outside the house. But I don’t think what we’re doing is making the family look weak. I think the family is weak right now.
The ticket is weak objectively, we’ve never pulled this low at this point in the race and it feels like it’s out of loyalty to the family that we’re saying, let’s see if we can shore this up and strengthen it. And no one’s saying they’re not going to support whoever’s on the ticket after this. We’re saying let’s put our best foot forward for whose ever on the ticket. So what do we actually know when we look at the data? This is a great question. If we were to say, let’s just theoretically get behind the radical notion that we should run the strongest candidate. I know that’s crazy. That’s a crazy idea that we just shouldn’t go with the one we have, but try to go with the strongest one. What do we know about the relative strengths of Biden, not vis-a-vis Trump, but vis-a-vis other people who could be candidates?
Jessica Yellin:
Okay, great question. And I think your family analogy is so apt because there’s this dynamic where other democrats aren’t even speaking out because they’re afraid of upsetting the patriarch and I don’t even mean why aren’t they speaking out calling for Biden to go, but where are the Democrats most telegenic and articulate and outspoken leaders countering Trump’s message in these past few days?
Amanda Doyle:
Thank you.
Jessica Yellin:
About shootings and about why don’t they make the parallel to school shootings? You’re so worried about guns and shootings in your case, let’s talk about school shootings or speaking up for who has used the most incendiary language. Anyway, that’s my little rant. I don’t understand why the Biden White House isn’t putting out all their best talkers to make the case, so that’s weird.
Amanda Doyle:
And now for nothing, why is it after 30 kids get shot up in a classroom, we are supposed to move on right after a thoughts and prayers tweet, but after this we have to shut down our campaign. Like what?
Jessica Yellin:
Yes, I mean, and Trump has literally said, “You just got to get over it and move on.” When it’s a six-year-old who’s shot, but not his ear. Anyway, the thing about shutting down the campaign, it’s sort of like a tradition that when something terrible happens, you take down your ads, wait a nice 24 hours and then put them up later. So it’s sort of old political behavior and I think the ads will go up in a nanosecond if they’re not up already, so that’ll come back. But your point is absolutely apt like where’s the desire to be aggressive and forward leaning?
You had asked about the numbers, okay, this is a very strange conversation to have because whenever I talk about polls, the audience gets so angry and says polls are always wrong and why do you trust them? It is correct that you cannot use a poll to predict the future. However, you can use both polling and focus groups, which is when political consultants sit down with small groups of people and talk to them week after week after week. I know people who’ve done this for all four years of the Biden administration and are continuing now. And you see the change in these conversations and when you see the change in these same polls, they might not be a perfect snapshot of America, but they are a consistent measure of a group of people and when you see a change in that group, it tells you something’s going on.
So what we’re seeing with the Biden polling is that it’s been pretty stable but it’s very low and even if sometimes he’s six points below Trump in some states, sometimes he’s too ahead. Right now, he’s behind Trump in all the swing states. That’s important to know. What we have to understand is that because of the way American voting works and the Electoral College, Democrats have to pull seven to 10% above the other guy in order to win the Electoral College. Remember how it’s all out of whack? We’ve talked about this. So Democrats always can win the popular vote but lose in the Electoral College. So to win in the Electoral College, you have to really win in the popular vote. So Democrats should be pacing ahead right now, Biden is not doing that. There’s a kind of thinking that basically his support is just diehard Democrats. People are going to vote. DL Hughley posted, “I’d vote for Biden if he were asleep on Fifth Avenue.” Making a joke about Trump’s Old Street.
Amanda Doyle:
Yeah, right.
Jessica Yellin:
So these are the people who’d vote for any Democrat asleep on Fifth Avenue. But the way Democrats are going to win this election is by getting out what we call low propensity voters, people who don’t always vote, people who aren’t super politically engaged, but you got to reach into whatever world they’re paying attention to media in and excite them and get them to think this is an election worth me getting off the couch. Biden is not doing that and they think that he’s not able to, right? That’s what all these wise men are saying and wise women to be honest, and you and I can see it, I just talked about this interview where he had all this opportunity to make an aggressive case and didn’t.
So who’s going to energize those low propensity voters? Right now, Kamala Harris is polling ahead of Biden against Trump and there are others in the Democratic Party who are superstars, who are behind. They’re not ahead of Biden in the polling, but the belief is if you give them the excitement of a convention that replaces the old candidate, puts a new, if you cover all this debate and dynamic change inside the Democratic Party that will draw huge media attention. It’ll be intriguing. It’ll create a new opportunity for this person to present themselves to America and make the case that they are the change candidate.
Amanda Doyle:
Is it really, is the future of Western civilization at this moment truly up to one man’s decision that he alone is at liberty to make based on his own perceptions and aspirations? Is that where we are? Is that the truth of what’s happening?
Jessica Yellin:
Yes.
Glennon Doyle:
And is he the only one that gets to decide?
Abby Wambach:
And PSO, he is Biden.
Jessica Yellin:
There’s not like a whole…
Abby Wambach:
We’re talking about Biden.
Jessica Yellin:
We’re talking about Biden, yes.
Glennon Doyle:
Is that the case or are there other people who get to help make this decision? Explain to us how this shit hits the fan here in terms of out or in Biden. Is it truly up to him and his little heart?
Jessica Yellin:
So fundamentally in the end, yes, it is up to him, he gets to decide. If you want to get into the real practical situation, here’s what’s going on, he has a campaign team. If they turn on him and his White House aides turn on him and the leadership of Congress turns on him and they all say, “We can’t do this.” In the end he can’t do it, but that’s not happening, right? So what it really comes down to is I was saying that prior to the shooting, there was all this action that was going to happen over the weekend to edge Biden out, and what that looks like is after the press conference Biden had last week, which seems a lifetime ago.
Glennon Doyle:
Yeah.
Jessica Yellin:
Hakeem Jeffries, the Minority Leader of the House went and met with him and they used all this public diplomatic political ease, but he basically said, “Here’s a list of members who say they cannot win their districts if you’re the president, if you’re running again in swing districts, so we’re not going to regain the house.” Then what you’re going to have is Chuck Schumer going to meet with Biden and saying, “Here’s the political reality.” And laying it out. And then you have Nancy Pelosi who can go in as the closer to say, “Mr. president, you got to exit.” Right, that’s sort of where the power lies and the influence and who can sort of really nudge him into changing his position. He has a group of a very tight-knit group of advisors around him who have sort of been his trusted people for decades. And then outside of that you have a White House staff, you have a campaign staff, all of whom can have an opinion, but the real ability to sort of maneuver him is through those congressional leaders and his closest aides. But ultimately, again, the decision is hi.
Glennon Doyle:
Those aides, those campaign managers, all of these people that are surrounding him that could say it looks like the writing’s on the wall. If they do, don’t they lose their power and positions?
Jessica Yellin:
Right.
Glennon Doyle:
Is this a group of people who all their political ambition is tied to Biden’s?
Jessica Yellin:
Yeah, the political calculus is they lose their position, they lose their access, they lose all of it if Biden goes. And so you understand what would motivate a person to not want to do that? I would frame it as in a lot of cases they convince themselves that he can win or that a change is too dangerous. It’s more like it’s a fear analysis, a fear posture where losing is almost inevitable, but sticking with our guy is safer than the option. And the problem is that there’s not a lot of penetration of the inner circle, so you don’t know what information they’re getting. In these environments, you got a lot of paranoia because people in the White House are now leaking. That’s another sign. The White House used to be on lockdown, it was hard to get leaks. Now it’s leaking like a sieve, which means Biden’s losing support in his own White House, same in the campaign. So you’re starting to see his own team sort of pull away from him in some ways, but he needs to feel some greater pressure than he already feels from the power influences in his world.
Amanda Doyle:
This is a recent poll. 56% of Democrats say Biden should withdraw. 72% of independents say he should. 6 in 10 liberals say so, 7 in 10 moderates say so, 7 in 10 among both white and Hispanic people. The people, the voters, this is what they say. I understand that, again, the family analogy, but at my job when there’s a crisis, when there’s an impending disaster for my business, I don’t get to panic and do nothing. Democrats are panicking and doing nothing. It’s not Biden and his inner circle. Yes, we would love for him to do the thing that is safest for the nation. He believes and has convinced himself, he’s doing the thing that safest for the nation. Where are the Democrats in leadership other than Adam Smith and some other folks that have come out to be bold and say, it is our job to make sure we’re running the best candidate. When Adam Smith, he’s this congressman from Washington, said, “The idea that we are going to slow walk into fascism because we don’t want to hurt somebody that we respects feelings.” I can’t even begin to tell you how angry that makes me.
Abby Wambach:
We heard that interview too, so good.
Jessica Yellin:
The other one who I thought was so impressive was Michael Bennett of Colorado, who was the first member of Congress to put his name to this and face and senator, the first senator and said, “We have a moral obligation to the kids of America to not do nothing, to speak up and fight for this if we have the opportunity to now and we do.” It was sort of like a have you no shame moment and people who had a lot of shame I guess.
Glennon Doyle:
And I want you to tell me that this is not true, so it’s just what, are we just like a lot of other families where we don’t call out our daddy because it would be too scary and just like families all over the world, we will go down, we will sacrifice ourselves so that we don’t hurt a man’s feelings or ego.
Jessica Yellin:
I mean, that is a part of the dynamic. I think another part of the dynamic is he’s the President of the United States. He’s a very powerful person and he has a very powerful apparatus around him and he is fighting to stay. He is not going, right? And they know that if you go up against him, and I think that there’s just a lot of political fear and survival fear. I don’t want to stick my neck out there in case it doesn’t go my way.
Amanda Doyle:
It’s all personal political calculus. Every single person, Biden has done his calculus. Every single senator and congress person is saying, “Do I have more to lose by sticking my head out than I have to win?”
Jessica Yellin:
There’s also this additional dynamic which I bring up knowing that I could get blow back for saying this right now, but there’s also a thing where some democratic voters are so unwilling to hear criticism of Biden that Democrats themselves are attacking anyone who has this conversation including elected officials. And they’re so unwilling to hear another point of view that they’re canceling subscriptions to newspapers that write about this. They are threatening to vote against Democrats who are talking about it. So part of it is Democrats also looking at their own constituency and not wanting to get ahead of their own voters.
Amanda Doyle:
And I get that, I really do. It’s this real fear of if we talk a bunch of trash about this guy about all the reasons he’s not good, then he ends up being at anyway, then we have given oxygen to that fire about how he’s not good. I totally get that. And I don’t think anyone is saying that they’re not going to support the ticket whoever’s on it after this. It’s just that the window is closing to make the strongest ticket and I would just like for someone to tell us that the reason why we’re going with this ticket is because it’s the strongest and not because the man who’s on the ticket really, really wants to be it.
Jessica Yellin:
I mean, you’re not going to find people telling you it’s the strongest ticket. Can I just add a little framing to why that is?
Amanda Doyle:
Please.
Jessica Yellin:
I had mentioned before these low propensity voters. I think one of the things is when you’re in a dysfunctional family, to go back to Glenn and Amanda, to your analogy, you kind of think this is what reality is, but you don’t know what it’s like to be in a family that communicates and is loving and you forget or don’t know what that was like. Go back and remember other successful presidential candidates like Barack Obama, what would he be doing right now? He would be out on the campaign trail talking about the shooting and then all the issues we’ve talked about making a case about gun safety, making a case about calling out your political opponents in ways that aren’t violent, but now that we’re going to do that, let me show you how to do that and then use that as an opportunity to call out his political opponent.
There’s a world in which your presidential candidate, you’re not just grading on this weird curve where if he doesn’t say something crazy and offensive, it’s a win. But where are your candidate’s actually making a positive case for the future and prosecuting the case against the opponent and that is not happening. And that is what you need to turn out those low propensity voters, not the super engaged people, the not engaged people, who’s going to reach them and there’s no one who’s going to tell you that Biden doing these baseline interviews is going to energize them.
Amanda Doyle:
The other thing that feels very disheartening about this is that we are in a situation where we have the last president before Biden refused to concede to a peaceful transfer of power and tried to stay in office. The entire basis of the current Democratic platform is despite all of the things they did that were amazing in this past administration, which is the really shame of all of it is we’re not talking about any of that because it’s all focused on his ability to communicate and be forceful and compelling.
Glennon Doyle:
And because they’re not talking about that, we have nothing.
Amanda Doyle:
Democrat, no, we have no people-
Glennon Doyle:
There’s no messaging, there’s nothing.
Amanda Doyle:
… who can carry a message or who are out there doing it. We have people who can, I’m looking at you Pete, where are you, Pete? But it’s framed in terms of existential crisis of democracy, right? And it is, and yet we have a situation in which the majority of Americans, democrats, independents and Republicans say, “This should not be the man on the ticket.” And our whole argument to vote for this man is he’s going to save democracy, but where is the democracy in this moment where we don’t even get to say who we think should be on the ticket? It is not where it’s internally inconsistent from a sniff test. We don’t get to have who we want, vote for us so we can save democracy.
Glennon Doyle:
You could be forgiven for people who say, isn’t this a little bit of king energy in itself? You talked so much about the importance of ceding power peacefully when it is time, perhaps it is your turn.
Jessica Yellin:
The irony is yes, is noteworthy
Amanda Doyle:
And not for nothing. I mean, but are we just not going to talk about how in his original, when we all agreed that this was the way and Biden has an incredible record on many things, this administration did a lot of wonderful things. I take nothing away from him except his ability to run again like, great job, good job, but-
Glennon Doyle:
Be the bridge [inaudible 00:31:57].
Amanda Doyle:
… are we not going to talk about how throughout the 2020 campaign he called himself a bridge and he called himself a transitional candidate and all but said he would be a one term president. Why is no one talking about that?
Glennon Doyle:
So Jessica, what are you hearing people say? Do we think the writings on the wall here? Do we think there’s hope for someone else? Who else would it be? Talk to us about what is possible next.
Jessica Yellin:
Okay. The moment we’re having this conversation is a very flux moment. So I’d go back to Friday and there were a lot of people who thought Biden would be out of the race by today or soon. Go to the weekend, the same people thought the conversation was over and now after Biden’s interview yesterday, the energy to replace him is back. There is a lot of interest in having some of these gray beards, I use that term loosely. It includes Nancy Pelosi go to him and tell him, “It’s time to go, sir, you’re going to have to help us find a way to make this a really graceful exit.” But the clock is ticking, so there’s a meeting of the DNC’s Rules Committee this Friday. They’re the ones who decide the process. So when people say there’s no process to replace Biden, that’s not true. The Democratic Party is a private business, it’s Rules Committee makes its rules. They can make the rules to replace him at their next meeting.
Amanda Doyle:
Who’s the key people involved in that?
Jessica Yellin:
It’s like a bunch of names of people who are behind the scenes. People you wouldn’t know.
Amanda Doyle:
But do we know where their allegiance is?
Jessica Yellin:
Not necessarily. I mean, not know, they work, no. But they also know that they have to represent the delegates well. They have to represent the party and if the party has decided to make a change, I think the Rules Committee would create the process. And there’s a couple of versions of this. First of all, for any of it to happen, the reason it’s so up to him is that for any of this to happen, he needs to bow out because he has close to 4,000 delegates who are committed to him. And so what you would need to have happen is for him to release his delegates and either ask them to vote for someone else of his choosing or tell them to vote their conscience, whoever they’d like. There’s a version where sort of like the Democratic Party thinkers imagine two versions. One is where the path is cleared for vice president Harris to fill that role. The argument being her name is already on the ticket. Now to be clear, that doesn’t have anything to do with ballots. People think that the ballots are already printed. The ballots do not get printed until a candidate is nominated. So there is time on the ballots, but she ran with Biden. So those same delegates who are committed to Biden are committed to her. So there’s a very [inaudible 00:35:10].
Amanda Doyle:
We’re talking about in the primaries, right?
Jessica Yellin:
Correct.
Amanda Doyle:
So we’re talking about the primaries where all the delegates are now, the states have voted in the primaries, they voted for Biden because that was pre any of this and they voted for him, it was Vice President Harris, President Biden on the ticket. So basically him coming off would automatically put her as the one who has been voted on-
Jessica Yellin:
Theoretically.
Amanda Doyle:
… and the delegates belong to.
Jessica Yellin:
Yes.
Amanda Doyle:
Theoretically.
Jessica Yellin:
It doesn’t because that’s not really a thing, it just is logical, right? Because the thing thing is when you get nominated at the convention and we could decide to nominate some other person, anyone, you know anybody could make that decision. The Democrats could make that decision. What Biden could do is sort of direct attention to Kamala Harris saying she’s already gotten those votes in the primary. She already has the campaign staff because it’s his and her staff and the money would legally flow to her pretty easily.
Amanda Doyle:
Right.
Jessica Yellin:
So you’d make a natural transition and the argument is if Biden’s running anyway, voters would be looking at Kamala Harris as a future president, assuming he couldn’t finish out the term anyway, so give her the opportunity to make the case in the strongest way possible for herself. She would represent dramatic change and youth and it would be a contrast to Trump and energize the party. That’s what her proponents say. There are others who say that would feel undemocratic like an anointment and it is more democratic to allow delegates to choose from a slate of candidates. That could include people like Governor Whitmer, Governor JB Pritzker, Governor Newsom, Pete Buttigieg, Governor Wes Moore, Governor Josh Shapiro. There’s a list, right? Some have said they don’t want to run, but give them the chance they might change.
Create a small primary process where each of them is allowed to have mini debates quickly or town halls with the networks, allow them to speak at the convention and then allow the delegates to vote. In that scenario, VP Harris would also be among the people voted on and if she gets the most votes there, then it would be seen that she was elected, not selected, and the people of that camp believe that’s a better way and a stronger way for her or any other candidate to come out. Then they get the nomination and go on to run. The problem is there are some deadlines before the convention that have to be met and that compresses the timeframe in which you get to decide will it be Biden and if not, which of these processes will take over?
Abby Wambach:
When does the convention begin?
Jessica Yellin:
August 19th, but there’s a vote of the Rules Committee this Friday.
Amanda Doyle:
So really the whole ball game is this Friday because they could also make it possible that it has to be Biden.
Jessica Yellin:
Yeah.
Amanda Doyle:
The rules can go either way. They could make the rules that basically make it impossible to go these other routes.
Jessica Yellin:
True. Basically, they could create a situation where there’s a roll call early, they nominate Biden and then those ballots do get printed and then it’s hard to pull that back. I don’t know, it’s like the Rules Committee is a little bit of a secret and how things work is not totally transparent. So some people say, “Friday is not the real deadline.” Some people say it’s Sunday. Some people say, “No, no, no, it’s not till August 6th or 7th.” I’m not quite sure, it’s very soon.
Amanda Doyle:
I think that the wise people who are in the light most favorable trying to do what is best for this country in their view should be very wary of the appearance of making it not possible for voters and the electorate to say what they want to happen. And I think it would be very dangerous for a rule to come down that made it impossible for that to happen because we’re already in a precarious spot with belief in institutions and…
Glennon Doyle:
The whole thing is fine. It’s like, “Well, the ballots are printed.” It’s like, “Well, I got to marry this dude because the tuna tartare are already ordered.”
Jessica Yellin:
Exactly.
Amanda Doyle:
Well, it’s ordering the tuna tartare early so you can say you have to marry him because the tuna tartare is ordered. Like the tuna tartare isn’t even ordered yet.
Glennon Doyle:
What’s your gut, Jessica, based on all of the buzz?
Jessica Yellin:
I mean there’s just such a groundswell to make a change. And I’ll say I spent Monday night watching the Republican convention and there’s a lot of energy on that floor and they did a lot of creative things to broaden their appeal and reach out to sort of working Americans. They had a whole populist appeal. They had multiracial social media influencer reaching younger and more diverse audience, and Democrats really need to find a way to counter that appeal. It seems like the train is moving again to replace him, but it could be very touch and go. I don’t know what’s going to happen right now. I will say that even after the convention, there’s a way to replace the person on the ticket, it can be done. It becomes less democratic at that point. I’d also add look at, like I find this riveting and it’s an important conversation, but if this weren’t the drama, we would’ve spent this entire time talking about who is JD Vance-
Amanda Doyle:
Exactly.
Glennon Doyle:
[inaudible 00:40:57].Jessica Yellin:
… or what violent comments has Trump made and there’s no longer such a clean focus on the opponent because Democrats are contending with this internal problem that they are under pressure to resolve quickly.
Amanda Doyle:
Which is the entire disaster of this thing. When Biden’s first campaign, was not Trump, it was say very little, let Trump say everything that he needs to say and let that show you who he is and who you should be voting for. And that was the strategy seemingly now he didn’t take the Super Bowl interview, it was going to still be let Trump show you who he is. So you want to vote for anyone who isn’t him. And that’s not what anyone’s talking about anymore for the rest of the time. It’s talking about is Biden the right one? That’s going to be it for the next… That strategy doesn’t work when Biden becomes the focus of the Biden campaign.
Jessica Yellin:
And what’s so weird to me is if he’s so determined to stay in, why is he not just accepting that he’s not a good communicator and flooding out the zone with the best communicators in his team? Again, why make Pete Buttigieg hide his light in a bushel? Is that the saying, I can’t remember.
Amanda Doyle:
Yeah, it is.
Jessica Yellin:
Whatever that saying is, he should be out talking all the time. Gina Raimondo. Why are they not pushing out all the administrations? They’re arguing that you’re not voting for a person, you’re voting for an administration, show the people who this administration is. So there almost seems like they’re also resigned to not running a camp. I don’t know what’s going on that front.
Glennon Doyle:
The resigned energy is terrifying.
Jessica Yellin:
Right.
Glennon Doyle:
Its unforgivable is what it is.
Can you please talk to us a little bit about JD Vance? Who the fuck is this guy?
Jessica Yellin:
So the thing that I think is important to help frame JD Vance, we will talk about his positions on abortion and all that. Before you do any of that, it’s important to understand that his world view is that America has been taken over by the sort of deep state, the administrative state that are sort of liberal institutional elites and in order to get America to its vibrant best place, you need to sort of purge government of those people and shake what he would call wokeness out of institutions. So that means sort of firing a lot of federal employees right from the beginning, reversing a lot of policies and regulations and pursuing a very… It’s an extremes extremist view of America, but it’s very specific and it’s partly populist, but it’s also aligned with Silicon Valley and his biggest backers are some of the richest billionaires in America, Silicon Valley bigwigs, who believe that tech and AI and new scientific breakthroughs are going to change us so much that government can’t keep up, but they can make the best decisions for the American people and we need to sort of peel back a lot of the government oversight so that they can innovate quickly and make us competitive.
Glennon Doyle:
Okay. So this is why the Elon Musk’s are putting $45 billion a month or whatever behind.
Jessica Yellin:
[inaudible 00:44:47].Glennon Doyle:
Yeah, whatever at that point.
Jessica Yellin:
At that point, yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
$45 million a month to the Trump campaign so they can lead.
Jessica Yellin:
Yeah.
Glennon Doyle:
Okay, huh. And what does that choice say to you? What does that choice right after the shooting, I know some people were saying, oh, this will be the moment, which reminded me of every single daughter who’s ever been like, “This is when dad changed.” It’s like, “No.”
Jessica Yellin:
That’s funny.
Glennon Doyle:
No, he’s not changing. He’s going to double down and triple down and quadruple down. So what does the choice of JD Vance signal?
Jessica Yellin:
That he’s very confident he’s going to win because if Trump were nervous, he would’ve picked more moderate person that could appeal across the aisle and appeal to Nikki Haley voters. It also means that if you are wondering if is he going to moderate his positions? No, he’s doubling down on the base voter project 2025 view of the world and he also is picking sort of a white guy, not a change candidate. He is young, JD Vance is young, but he’s really sort of going with what the billionaires want him to do in this case. And I’d add that JD Vance is the preferred candidate of the Biden campaign. The Democrats believe that he’s so extremist that he will turn off swing voters and if you have a campaign that has vim and aggressive postures, they could take him on and make that case. Just to sort of fill that in, JD Vance is against abortion even in the case of rape. He only makes an exception for the life of the mother. He has very conservative or far-right positions, is against gender-affirming care. He wants to strip language that’s LGBTQ and sort of female-friendly from a lot of our government policies. I mean, I could go on.
Amanda Doyle:
He’s anti-IVF. He has suggested that we should get rid of no-fault divorces. I mean, it’s like turning back the clock in a very dramatic way.
Jessica Yellin:
Yeah. And then he scrambles things a bit because while he’s for the border wall and he says that Biden’s open border policies are destroying America, he also adopts some typically now liberal positions like he wants to raise the minimum wage, he wants to have tariffs on some imported stuff, things that sort of help the American worker. So there’s ways in which he’s extremely far-right on social policies, especially as regards women and the LGBTQ community, but when it regards working men, he’ll adopt a more populist and sort of seemingly liberal frame which widens his appeal.
Amanda Doyle:
He’s also an unabashed communicator with a willingness to be mean in a way that’s an asset to a campaign. He can use his words and is not afraid to use them in a way that Democrats have historically not been willing to step up to the plate and match.
Glennon Doyle:
For example, a few years ago when he called Donald Trump the Hitler of America.
Amanda Doyle:
Yeah.
Jessica Yellin:
And then Donald Trump didn’t care.
Glennon Doyle:
Which you would think…
Jessica Yellin:
He forgave him.
Glennon Doyle:
No, you would think that would be a deal breaker for a man with a big ego until you think a little bit harder and think maybe it’s not an insult at all to Donald Trump.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah.
Jessica Yellin:
Right after the shooting, Vance put out a statement essentially saying that Biden and Democrats had used language calling Trump a fascist and that is the sort of incendiary language that led to this violence, which is a big time gaslight, but it’s the sort of forward leaning aggressive posture that Trump likes and that is actually very effective for a campaign from a vice presidential candidate. The vice presidential candidate is usually the one that makes the harshest attacks and Vance is very comfortable leading into that.
Glennon Doyle:
Yes, bad cop. When you mentioned gaslighting, I just want to say this is that I have been thinking and struggling and wrestling nonstop with what to say and how to say it because my main goal is to use whatever small platform I have to do what I can to avoid this country falling into fascism. It seems to me that the options presented to people like me right now are pretend you don’t see what you see and toe whatever future line is or I’m just not going to do that. I’m going to say what I see and how I feel in the moment. I’m not going to gaslight other people by saying, “I don’t see what you see when Biden speaks.” But when it is time, you will see me standing behind whoever it is doing whatever I need to do to avoid Donald Trump becoming president whether that is fruitful or not, but I’m not going to pretend that I don’t see what I see in the meantime.
Jessica Yellin:
May I ask you a question, Glennon?
Glennon Doyle:
Yes.
Jessica Yellin:
Because you’re the person who’s best at this and at words that are difficult but can be said without offending people, which is when you say, I’m going to speak what I see, how do you language that? What would you say? Help other people who want to be able to say that too.
Glennon Doyle:
What I am experiencing is that in the lack of good ideas, a bad idea will take precedent over no idea. And that is I saw that all the time at my classroom in third grade, I see it in my family and right now I see it in the country. The energy surrounding this bad idea is so much bigger. My anger at the Democratic Party right now is as big as my anger at the Republican Party, maybe even bigger. I see in when I’m listening to interviews, I feel a fury that I cannot put into words yet that this party has not faced the hard truth of what they were seeing every single day for years before this moment. And it very much reminds me of the fact that we as a people will allow our families to crumble. We will allow our communities to crumble, our countries to crumble, perhaps our planet to crumble because we do not want to challenge the fragility of an old white man.
I am furious about it. I feel concerned about everyone that I love because it feels like we have to shut up and not say the truth like every person in a family does with a father who’s leading poorly or I think it’s super important that we allow the truth to live right now and we allow the truth to guide us towards the next best decision. And so I am okay with some anger right now. I’m okay with a little bit of chaos. I’m okay with people speaking what they see in hopes that that leads us to a better truer next step. But this silencing of all of us, this gaslighting, you do not see what you are seeing.
I am starting to get to a point where I understand the people who say it’s all the same, the right side’s the same as the left side, the left side’s the same as… I see a lot of king energy. I see a lot of gaslighting energy. I see a lot of you do not see what you see, you do not hear what you hear. So I’m ready, I understand that people will be furious with what I’m saying right now. In order to survive this, I’m going to say what I feel and see in the moment and then the next day I’m going to do that again and then the next day I’m going to do that again. But I’m not going to lie today for some future promise that people make that never comes to fruition anyway. I want to be a part of the fomenting that maybe leads to something better because we have to demand more of the Democratic Party. If that’s our family, we have to demand that it’s better because this is absolutely unacceptable.
Amanda Doyle:
Amen.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s how I feel.
Amanda Doyle:
I feel exactly like you feel, Glennon. We have seen what and a political movement based on fear where it leads us. We have seen an administration based on fear, a whole brand, which is exactly what Trump has done over and over. Fear them, fear that they’re the reason you’re in danger, you’re in danger you need to stick with us so we can get rid of them, all of that. And I feel like how dare the administration come to us with a fear-based reason why we can’t have that, okay? So yes, okay, it’s not perfect. Yes, he’s really old. But it’s too scary. It’s too scary to try something else. It’s too risky to try something else. You can’t have that thing, that thing that you can imagine that’s better than this. We would love to give it to you, but you can’t have it. I’m so sorry.
The fear keeps us in this place of what is instead of having faith in what we can imagine, which is better. And I reject the idea that our choices are to go with that Trump administration who is leading with fear or this Democratic Party that is leading us with fear that says, this is the scraps you get and just try to turn off that vision of something more and better and the faith in democracy and the faith in the American people that reveals is very little. And I would like to have a Democratic Party that has faith in democracy and faith in the American people and faith in gathering together the electorate at that convention to choose wisely. And if Biden wants to be up there and run in with it, great. Great. And if he wins, I’m with him. But we cannot have two choices that are both fear-based.
Abby Wambach:
Yeah. May the best idea win and it seems that we don’t know what the best… We don’t know anything. It feels like they’re just saying, they’re forcing us to believe that Biden is the best idea and we’re like-
Glennon Doyle:
And then they say…
Abby Wambach:
… really?
Glennon Doyle:
Okay, fine, so what we want you to do is don’t lead with the candidate then. If you’re not excited about our candidate, just lead with the party. Okay, give me something for that because I understand the young people who are saying to me, “You can’t even get your shit together to have somebody who can debate, but you want me to think that you’re handling everything else that I can’t see better than that?” Oh, I’m sorry, the one forward facing thing that you’re doing is fucked up this bad. And so I should trust that the million other things that I can’t see are going well. I understand that feeling. I don’t know.
Amanda Doyle:
Can’t put it back in a box.
Abby Wambach:
Good times.
Jessica Yellin:
I will say they do have a very able people in their campaign and in the White House who are sort of I think also kind of on this boat that they can’t get off, on the spaceship that they can’t get off. There are…
Amanda Doyle:
Sure they can. Sure they can there’s millions of families-
Jessica Yellin:
[inaudible 00:57:30].Amanda Doyle:
… across this country that have to deal with their own fucking messes and they do it every day. There’s millions of family businesses that face crises, that need succession plans, that have older people and patriarchs and matriarchs that they have to gracefully take care of while the next leadership comes to mind. Americans do this every fucking day. Democratic Party, why does my family of four people have a more sophisticated succession plan for what happens when I die than the Democratic Party on which the future of western civilization depends. That is inexcusable bullshit. You should have seen this coming. You should have done your jobs. Now what we are noticing is that you didn’t, and all we’re asking for is the chance to get it right instead of you explaining to us why we can’t have it right.
Abby Wambach:
Democratic Party has a humility problem right now, and that’s the thing that they’ve been operating under that like, “Oh, we are the nicest. We are the most conscious of this country. We would do the right thing.” And here we are and this is the test. What are you going to do Democrats? Are you going to show up and actually be what you say you are? Be what you say you are.
Glennon Doyle:
Okay, so Jessica, what should we watch next? What should our eyes be on next?
Abby Wambach:
What are we looking towards?
Glennon Doyle:
Tell us what to do next?
Jessica Yellin:
I mean, the thing that’s happening or two, one is the behind the scenes maneuvers that are kind of like I’m saying, revving up again to try to ease Biden out. If there’s meaningful action, one would look for it to happen by Friday. The Rules Committee meets on Friday, there’s a separate deadline on Sunday. There’s this other vote on the, I can’t remember, the 6th or 7th of August. So that’s sort of in the next couple of days, are we going to see some of the elders of the party speaking out, pushing him out, to say it gracelessly. At the same time you’re watching the RNC to see what their messaging is and Trump is expected to speak, no, he will speak on Thursday. So you want to hear what Vance and Trump are saying is their agenda as part of thinking about what the Democrats messaging is.
I would also watch where are the other candidates, all these potentials, what are they saying and doing? That’s on the hard politics, one of the biggest unknowns to me right now is will Trump be able to own this kind of message that Democrats cannot call him a threat to democracy because that is therefore incendiary language that incites violence. I mean, if Barack Obama were leading this, he would have a really effective message in response. I don’t see that coming yet from Biden. So who in the Democratic Party is able to articulate that and push back and what is that push back? It’s not going to be Mrs. Obama. There’s all this polling that shows she rates very well, but she’s not going to run for office. She’s not going to run. But I do think you’ll hear and see Barack Obama on the campaign trail.
I think his unique contribution is he frames an argument so well that once he’s out there driving a message, you start to hear that message from all other Democrats on the campaign trail. So he doesn’t even need to be at the top of the ticket, he just needs to be out in public talking. So other people understand the frame for pushing their case. Pete Buttigieg is also good at that. And it’s really like a two-week window. Is this going to happen in the next two weeks? If not, something dramatic can happen down the line, but you can’t really count on that. I also think we’re living in these crazy times and I wouldn’t be surprised if two more events happen between now and the election. That’s scramble things again. It’s very hard to plan for the future when unpredictable stuff is happening endlessly.
Amanda Doyle:
I will just say last thing is that I feel like a lot of the fear comes from, “Oh God, we can’t have unpredictable things. We can’t have have a convention that’s unpredictable and wild and chaotic.” Part of our problem is that everything seems choreographed and nothing seems real or organic or chaotic or actually happening.
Jessica Yellin:
Exactly.
Amanda Doyle:
It seems like this choreographed event and we get to see the outcome that was already predestined. I think it would be incredible for engagement and excitement for us to actually see something fucking happen in real time and people express their voice and we end up with a candidate.
Glennon Doyle:
What if we actually saw something that looked like democracy happening that might be exciting, that might make people believe that we’re a democracy.
Jessica Yellin:
The political insiders feared that will look like 1968 and it’s chaos and danger. But the counter to that is exactly as you’re saying. It will look exciting. And by the way, that drives media interest, one of the problems is that people are super disinterested and disengaged. I get told our candidates and our politicians are out there, but they can’t break through, the media won’t cover them. Well, an convention with an unknown outcome would get endless media attention, the whole nation focus. Those low propensity voters, it would break through their media bubble. So that is one of the arguments for making this change now. People are scared of change though.
Glennon Doyle:
All right. Well, they better get ready. Okay, Jessica, I truly have spent a lot of time thinking about you all doing you especially, and I have a couple other friends that are in this every day. I am awed by.
Abby Wambach:
Grateful for.
Glennon Doyle:
I’m deeply grateful. I cannot imagine how unbelievably difficult it must be every day to stay sane, to stay grounded, and to deliver difficult information with the clarity and wisdom and groundedness and gentleness and kindness and that you do. And I seriously, I’m so deeply grateful and I am thinking about you and I am just in your corner and will be energetically loving you throughout this.
Jessica Yellin:
Thank you. Thank you. That means so much. May I say there’s two things. One is if folks want facts, I put out a newsletter that’s very grounded. I try to keep it calm and it gives you the kind of information you can use to have conversations and form your own opinions. So if people want to check out the News Not Noise letter, that’s awesome.
And then there’s one tool I’ve learned that I would love to share, which is a lot of times when I’m doing the news and scrolling social media and reading all this stuff, or even listening to a podcast and I get that triggered feeling like I suddenly feel my anxiety rise. I’m so trained to just push it down and move on. And I think a lot of us are, but the better practice I’m learning, because I know we’ve talked about this and I’ve developed some tools, is when you feel that thing grab you, like I’m panicked. If you put it down and then you do the trauma therapy thing, you ask your body what it’s feeling and allow yourself, is it fear? Is it rage? Is it frustration? Let yourself have the emotion deeply, I’m sure it lasts 45 seconds and move on. And then you can go back to the news from a more neutral place where you’re centered. And that strategy has helped me so much, and as folks are getting engaged in politics, again, you might practice this in other parts of your life, but I’d encourage folks to try it when they’re engaging with politics too. It really makes a difference.
Glennon Doyle:
And Jessica, how do they find your newsletter? Where do they go?
Jessica Yellin:
It’s on Substack and it’s called the News Not Noise letter.
Glennon Doyle:
I’ve been talking to my sister a lot about this lately. I am committed more than I ever have before then to doing this a third way. I will not go on the ride every single day, I won’t. I have this one wild and precious life, and I will not allow the news cycle that is dependent not on democracy. That’s not the goal. The goal is to keep us panicked so that we will keep coming back for more, right? That’s it. So I’m committed to doing what I can do, but not doing it in a way that hijacks my entire life and makes me unavailable to myself and the people that I love all day. So this is a really beautiful third way of, we cannot mistake entertainment for being informed, right? We say, “I just want to be informed.” And then we spend all day in this cycle of clickbait and whatever. So Jessica’s a third way for me to not disengage, but to engage with what is meaningful and can actually make a difference.
Abby Wambach:
News, news, yes.
Jessica Yellin:
Thank you. You guys are amazing.
Glennon Doyle:
That’s good, you should share that with Jessica. All right, we love you. Go do your 7 trillion other things that you’re doing today and people you’re meeting with, and just thank you for keeping us grounded. Pod Squad, we love you. All we can promise is that we are going to do this with you and we’re going to be honest so that you trust us today that we’re telling you how we actually feel and what we actually see. And then that means that in two weeks, if it’s different and when it’s different, you can trust us then too, because we weren’t pretending this whole time.
Amanda Doyle:
Okay. Bye Pod Squad.
Abby Wambach:
See you Pods.
Amanda Doyle:
I’m sure will hear from you in the voicemails. Bye.
Glennon Doyle:
If this podcast means something to you, it would mean so much to us. If you’d be willing to take 30 seconds to do these three things first, can you please follow or subscribe to We Can Do Hard Things? Following the pod helps you because you’ll never miss an episode and it helps us because you’ll never miss an episode. To do this, just go to the We Can Do Hard Things show page on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Odyssey, or wherever you listen to podcasts. And then just tap the plus sign in the upper right-hand corner or click on follow. This is the most important thing for the pod. While you’re there, if you’d be willing to give us a five star rating and review and share an episode you loved with a friend, we would be so grateful. We appreciate you very much. We Can Do Hard Things is created and hosted by Glennon Doyle, Abby Wambach, and Amanda Doyle. In partnership with Odyssey. Our executive producer is Jenna Weiss-Berman, and the show is produced by Lauren LoGrasso, Allison Schott, Dynna Cabana and Bill Schultz.